Bookmarker is a personal project by @dellsystem to help with retaining reading material. Source on GitHub.

Among the Web pioneers of South Park and Multimedia Gulch, there were complicated feelings about how their seminal contributions to the rise of the Internet, and the transformation of the city, had turned out. Brian Behlendorf offers a joking apology for the banner ad and the tracking “cookie,” which he’d had an important role in inventing as part of the founding team at HotWired. He’s appalled by the “surveillance economy” that it helped seed. At the same time, he’s proud of the way in which the idea of collaborative, open-source software has become foundational to almost every dimension of computing and the Internet.

John Battelle says a crucial mistake at HotWired was building the advertising system as a separate bit of technology—called an ad server—rather than it being integrated with the editorial content. “My idea was editorial purity—we don’t want to mix our chocolate and our peanut butter. So they built an ad server, they built Apache, they built the whole shooting match, and open-sourced it, and editorial was detached from advertising and identity, and context was detached from advertising. Then Facebook put it back together: they knew every single person and knew who they were, they knew the context they were in, and they used the same systems for advertising as they did for content. That was the end of the open Web.”

Battelle and many others are drawn to the idea of a far more decentralized Internet, where control lies with the people on the “edge,” rather than with centralized platforms like Facebook and Apple and Google. That’s closer to what the Internet promised in its early days.

—p.362 Epilogue (355) by Jonathan Weber 1 hour, 16 minutes ago