Bookmarker is a personal project by @dellsystem to help with retaining reading material. Source on GitHub.
6

For the right, San Francisco is exhibit number one for the argument that progressive policies on crime and drugs have ruined Democratic-run cities. Among moderate Democrats, San Francisco is a great example of the failures of anti-growth liberalism, as outlined in the “abundance” theory popularized by journalists Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson. The progressive left has its diagnosis too: If only the tech companies and the billionaires weren’t so greedy, there’d be plenty of resources to solve social problems like homelessness.

There is certainly some truth in each of these. Yet as I revisited the remarkable history of the past three decades and interviewed more than two hundred people at the center of events, I found that none of the pat explanations really captured what had happened in San Francisco. The deeper story, in my view, is only partly about the various ways that city government fumbled the ball, or that the tech industry’s heedlessness created needless strife. It’s also about how the intensifying forces of techno-capitalism operate by their own logic. Considering the city and its tech industry as protagonists in a wider drama leads to more nuanced and richer interpretations.

ok boomer

—p.6 Foreword (1) by Jonathan Weber 38 minutes ago

For the right, San Francisco is exhibit number one for the argument that progressive policies on crime and drugs have ruined Democratic-run cities. Among moderate Democrats, San Francisco is a great example of the failures of anti-growth liberalism, as outlined in the “abundance” theory popularized by journalists Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson. The progressive left has its diagnosis too: If only the tech companies and the billionaires weren’t so greedy, there’d be plenty of resources to solve social problems like homelessness.

There is certainly some truth in each of these. Yet as I revisited the remarkable history of the past three decades and interviewed more than two hundred people at the center of events, I found that none of the pat explanations really captured what had happened in San Francisco. The deeper story, in my view, is only partly about the various ways that city government fumbled the ball, or that the tech industry’s heedlessness created needless strife. It’s also about how the intensifying forces of techno-capitalism operate by their own logic. Considering the city and its tech industry as protagonists in a wider drama leads to more nuanced and richer interpretations.

ok boomer

—p.6 Foreword (1) by Jonathan Weber 38 minutes ago
23

Then living in Amsterdam, Rossetto flew to San Francisco in early 1991 for the Macworld trade show, on a mission to recruit collaborators for a new magazine that would lead, and chronicle, the massive upheaval he saw coming. He was messianic in his conviction that new technologies would force a top-to-bottom reordering of culture, politics, business and every type of human relationship. This was something to be celebrated, not feared: It was nothing less than an epochal opportunity to throw off the chains of the mundane modernity imposed by soulless corporations and corrupt governments, and empower the people with magical new tools. With his flowing brown hair, brooding gaze and gift for grand pronouncements, Rossetto presented like a prophet, or at least a poet, of an emerging new world, clear in his vision and eager to enlighten the masses.

alas
(founder of wired)

—p.23 South Park and the Birth of the Web (11) by Jonathan Weber 35 minutes ago

Then living in Amsterdam, Rossetto flew to San Francisco in early 1991 for the Macworld trade show, on a mission to recruit collaborators for a new magazine that would lead, and chronicle, the massive upheaval he saw coming. He was messianic in his conviction that new technologies would force a top-to-bottom reordering of culture, politics, business and every type of human relationship. This was something to be celebrated, not feared: It was nothing less than an epochal opportunity to throw off the chains of the mundane modernity imposed by soulless corporations and corrupt governments, and empower the people with magical new tools. With his flowing brown hair, brooding gaze and gift for grand pronouncements, Rossetto presented like a prophet, or at least a poet, of an emerging new world, clear in his vision and eager to enlighten the masses.

alas
(founder of wired)

—p.23 South Park and the Birth of the Web (11) by Jonathan Weber 35 minutes ago
34

At the very same time, another group at the University of Illinois, led by a combative, hyper-intelligent twenty-eight-year-old named Marc Andreessen, was building a Web browser, called Mosaic. Andreessen had grown up in rural Wisconsin and had big ambitions, one of which was to make money, so he was all ears when he got a call from Jim Clark, a computer graphics expert who’d made a fortune with his first company, Silicon Graphics, before being pushed out by his investors. Like Andreessen, who resented the pretentiousness and privilege of the Stanford and MIT grads, Clark had a huge chip on his shoulder, having never gotten the respect from the Silicon Valley elite that he thought he deserved. Clark persuaded Andreessen to leave Champaign and come west, and together they formed Mosaic Communications, soon to be renamed Netscape, to commercialize Web software.

Shortly thereafter, Rob McCool and the other Illinois grad students Behlendorf had been working with remotely had some news: “They tell the list, sorry, we’re not gonna be able to release any more updates. We’re all leaving school and going to join this startup in Silicon Valley,” Behlendorf recalled.

lol

—p.34 South Park and the Birth of the Web (11) by Jonathan Weber 33 minutes ago

At the very same time, another group at the University of Illinois, led by a combative, hyper-intelligent twenty-eight-year-old named Marc Andreessen, was building a Web browser, called Mosaic. Andreessen had grown up in rural Wisconsin and had big ambitions, one of which was to make money, so he was all ears when he got a call from Jim Clark, a computer graphics expert who’d made a fortune with his first company, Silicon Graphics, before being pushed out by his investors. Like Andreessen, who resented the pretentiousness and privilege of the Stanford and MIT grads, Clark had a huge chip on his shoulder, having never gotten the respect from the Silicon Valley elite that he thought he deserved. Clark persuaded Andreessen to leave Champaign and come west, and together they formed Mosaic Communications, soon to be renamed Netscape, to commercialize Web software.

Shortly thereafter, Rob McCool and the other Illinois grad students Behlendorf had been working with remotely had some news: “They tell the list, sorry, we’re not gonna be able to release any more updates. We’re all leaving school and going to join this startup in Silicon Valley,” Behlendorf recalled.

lol

—p.34 South Park and the Birth of the Web (11) by Jonathan Weber 33 minutes ago
35

“We thought it’d be really nice if the Web stayed open and didn’t go the way of the desktop,” Behlendorf says. “A browser is a lot harder to build than a server. But we felt if we could keep the server side open, we’d have a shot.” He’d just seen a documentary about a Native American tribe, and its name had a nice resonance with the patches they shared to improve their code. The Apache Group was formed, with twenty-one initial members, and would prove an extraordinary success: The free, open-source Apache Web server would run a majority of all websites on the global Internet for more than fifteen years.

Back at HotWired, Behlendorf and his software solved one key problem: providing the technical foundation that would organize and control the content and interactions that are at the core of a website. But that was just the beginning. Rossetto at first insisted on requiring registration for HotWired’s users, so Behlendorf and the tech team had to figure out how such a registration would work. How could the Web server know whether a particular visitor was registered or not? They came up with the idea of a digital token that would be discreetly left on a visitor’s machine, so the website would recognize them the next time they visited—something we now know as a cookie.

the real which way, western man dilemma for tech: work on open source software in obscurity, or become a venture capitalist by selling your soul to the devil?

—p.35 South Park and the Birth of the Web (11) by Jonathan Weber 32 minutes ago

“We thought it’d be really nice if the Web stayed open and didn’t go the way of the desktop,” Behlendorf says. “A browser is a lot harder to build than a server. But we felt if we could keep the server side open, we’d have a shot.” He’d just seen a documentary about a Native American tribe, and its name had a nice resonance with the patches they shared to improve their code. The Apache Group was formed, with twenty-one initial members, and would prove an extraordinary success: The free, open-source Apache Web server would run a majority of all websites on the global Internet for more than fifteen years.

Back at HotWired, Behlendorf and his software solved one key problem: providing the technical foundation that would organize and control the content and interactions that are at the core of a website. But that was just the beginning. Rossetto at first insisted on requiring registration for HotWired’s users, so Behlendorf and the tech team had to figure out how such a registration would work. How could the Web server know whether a particular visitor was registered or not? They came up with the idea of a digital token that would be discreetly left on a visitor’s machine, so the website would recognize them the next time they visited—something we now know as a cookie.

the real which way, western man dilemma for tech: work on open source software in obscurity, or become a venture capitalist by selling your soul to the devil?

—p.35 South Park and the Birth of the Web (11) by Jonathan Weber 32 minutes ago
35

Tim O’Reilly, a computer book publisher based in Sebastopol, a town in rural Sonoma County about fifty miles north of the city, had already seen that this new construct of the website could effectively be an advertisement in itself. The company had also built Global Network Navigator, an early tool for finding things on the Web, and it had an ad across the bottom of the screen. Another example was Prodigy, the IBM service, which had a blinking advertisement that would take over the whole page when it was clicked. Battelle suggested a horizontal graphical advertisement, and Rossetto had the idea of putting it at the top of the page, where it would disappear as people scrolled down. When clicked on, rather than taking over the page, it would take you to the website of the advertiser.

And so the banner ad, a core Internet advertising format to this day, was born.

—p.35 South Park and the Birth of the Web (11) by Jonathan Weber 31 minutes ago

Tim O’Reilly, a computer book publisher based in Sebastopol, a town in rural Sonoma County about fifty miles north of the city, had already seen that this new construct of the website could effectively be an advertisement in itself. The company had also built Global Network Navigator, an early tool for finding things on the Web, and it had an ad across the bottom of the screen. Another example was Prodigy, the IBM service, which had a blinking advertisement that would take over the whole page when it was clicked. Battelle suggested a horizontal graphical advertisement, and Rossetto had the idea of putting it at the top of the page, where it would disappear as people scrolled down. When clicked on, rather than taking over the page, it would take you to the website of the advertiser.

And so the banner ad, a core Internet advertising format to this day, was born.

—p.35 South Park and the Birth of the Web (11) by Jonathan Weber 31 minutes ago
36

There was still a problem though: If clicking an ad took you to the advertiser’s website, that advertiser would need to, um, have a website. And nobody had a website.

Steuer’s childhood friend and now-housemate Jonathan Nelson, a music producer and event promoter as well as a techie, saw the opportunity. He’d been following the emergence of the Web, and was especially keen on figuring out how the Internet might help the music business. Now he recognized that companies would want websites. So together with his brother Matthew, Brian Behlendorf and a programmer named Cliff Skolnick, he started a company called Organic Online and rented an office just upstairs from Wired. Behlendorf began moonlighting for Organic, shuttling between the two floors as he built the technical foundations for both HotWired and its advertisers. Nelson lugged around a computer with Behlendorf’s software on it to show marketers what they were talking about. When HotWired launched in the fall of 1994, five of the seven advertisers had websites built by Organic.

—p.36 South Park and the Birth of the Web (11) by Jonathan Weber 31 minutes ago

There was still a problem though: If clicking an ad took you to the advertiser’s website, that advertiser would need to, um, have a website. And nobody had a website.

Steuer’s childhood friend and now-housemate Jonathan Nelson, a music producer and event promoter as well as a techie, saw the opportunity. He’d been following the emergence of the Web, and was especially keen on figuring out how the Internet might help the music business. Now he recognized that companies would want websites. So together with his brother Matthew, Brian Behlendorf and a programmer named Cliff Skolnick, he started a company called Organic Online and rented an office just upstairs from Wired. Behlendorf began moonlighting for Organic, shuttling between the two floors as he built the technical foundations for both HotWired and its advertisers. Nelson lugged around a computer with Behlendorf’s software on it to show marketers what they were talking about. When HotWired launched in the fall of 1994, five of the seven advertisers had websites built by Organic.

—p.36 South Park and the Birth of the Web (11) by Jonathan Weber 31 minutes ago
37

Yahoo, a simple, category-based index of Web content founded in 1994 by Stanford graduate students David Filo and Jerry Yang, had at first vowed never to take advertising (they told me as much directly when they came to visit the LA Times in early 1995). Many of the pre-Web Internet pioneers, mostly academics and researchers, were still fighting the commercialization of the Internet. But the writing was now very clearly on the wall. Before the year was out Filo and Yang changed their tune and raised money from Sequoia Capital, king of the venture capital firms, and would go public in 1996.

It wasn’t all about the money though, not yet anyway: The idealistic vision of the Internet as a liberating tool of personal empowerment and community connection, open to use and build upon, and free of censorship and profiteering, still burned bright, especially in San Francisco.

—p.37 South Park and the Birth of the Web (11) by Jonathan Weber 31 minutes ago

Yahoo, a simple, category-based index of Web content founded in 1994 by Stanford graduate students David Filo and Jerry Yang, had at first vowed never to take advertising (they told me as much directly when they came to visit the LA Times in early 1995). Many of the pre-Web Internet pioneers, mostly academics and researchers, were still fighting the commercialization of the Internet. But the writing was now very clearly on the wall. Before the year was out Filo and Yang changed their tune and raised money from Sequoia Capital, king of the venture capital firms, and would go public in 1996.

It wasn’t all about the money though, not yet anyway: The idealistic vision of the Internet as a liberating tool of personal empowerment and community connection, open to use and build upon, and free of censorship and profiteering, still burned bright, especially in San Francisco.

—p.37 South Park and the Birth of the Web (11) by Jonathan Weber 31 minutes ago
46

Netscape’s 1995 IPO had awakened the venture capitalists of Silicon Valley and the bankers of Wall Street to the promise of the Internet, and they were beginning to stoke a financial tsunami that would sweep across the city in the late 1990s as the consumer Internet was born.

Modern venture capital had come into its own in Silicon Valley in the 1960s, with pioneers such as Arthur Rock, who’d back Intel and Apple, seeing an opportunity in funding California tech companies that the East Coast bankers of the day considered too risky and too far away. They developed a straightforward playbook: raise money from institutional investors such as pension funds and university endowments, and put it into select technology startups a little bit at a time. Though Rock and some others would make huge fortunes, venture capital for decades occupied a modest nook in the palace of high finance, invisible even to much of the business world. In Silicon Valley, it wasn’t always respected by the technologists who were taking the money; Andy Grove, the Intel cofounder, once likened it to selling real estate.

But the explosive growth of the personal computer industry in the 1980s had started to raise the stakes, and a handful of VCs began to emerge as important kingmakers, deciding which startups were worth backing. For entrepreneurs, in turn, not everyone’s money was equally green: winning the support of a prestigious, top-tier VC was a potent endorsement, helpful for getting publicity and recruiting talent and doing deals.

—p.46 The "Motor City" of the Internet (39) by Jonathan Weber 28 minutes ago

Netscape’s 1995 IPO had awakened the venture capitalists of Silicon Valley and the bankers of Wall Street to the promise of the Internet, and they were beginning to stoke a financial tsunami that would sweep across the city in the late 1990s as the consumer Internet was born.

Modern venture capital had come into its own in Silicon Valley in the 1960s, with pioneers such as Arthur Rock, who’d back Intel and Apple, seeing an opportunity in funding California tech companies that the East Coast bankers of the day considered too risky and too far away. They developed a straightforward playbook: raise money from institutional investors such as pension funds and university endowments, and put it into select technology startups a little bit at a time. Though Rock and some others would make huge fortunes, venture capital for decades occupied a modest nook in the palace of high finance, invisible even to much of the business world. In Silicon Valley, it wasn’t always respected by the technologists who were taking the money; Andy Grove, the Intel cofounder, once likened it to selling real estate.

But the explosive growth of the personal computer industry in the 1980s had started to raise the stakes, and a handful of VCs began to emerge as important kingmakers, deciding which startups were worth backing. For entrepreneurs, in turn, not everyone’s money was equally green: winning the support of a prestigious, top-tier VC was a potent endorsement, helpful for getting publicity and recruiting talent and doing deals.

—p.46 The "Motor City" of the Internet (39) by Jonathan Weber 28 minutes ago
71

In normal times, venture capitalists would carefully vet a startup, put in a little money, see how things went and then maybe put in more. If the company did well, they might join with other VCs to put in larger sums, and if the company continued to grow and started to turn a profit, then it would be time for a sale, or an IPO. It typically took at least four or five years, and often more, to get to the “liquidity event” where investors and employee shareholders could cash in.

These were not normal times.

Netscape had gone public just sixteen months after it was founded, and the bankers and venture capitalists had every reason to feed the suddenly ravenous investor appetite for all things Internet. A ramshackle parade of IPOs began to take shape, and by 1998 there were multiple Internet IPOs seemingly every week. In the fall of that year a San Francisco outfit called The Globe, a too-early social network created by a couple of Cornell students, established the precedent that a company need not have much of a business at all to convince IPO investors of its value, only a little Internet sizzle. The company had posted a loss of $11.5 million for the first nine months of the year on sales of $2.7 million, but after its IPO it was somehow worth more than $800 million.

—p.71 The Bible of the Dot-com Boom (67) by Jonathan Weber 27 minutes ago

In normal times, venture capitalists would carefully vet a startup, put in a little money, see how things went and then maybe put in more. If the company did well, they might join with other VCs to put in larger sums, and if the company continued to grow and started to turn a profit, then it would be time for a sale, or an IPO. It typically took at least four or five years, and often more, to get to the “liquidity event” where investors and employee shareholders could cash in.

These were not normal times.

Netscape had gone public just sixteen months after it was founded, and the bankers and venture capitalists had every reason to feed the suddenly ravenous investor appetite for all things Internet. A ramshackle parade of IPOs began to take shape, and by 1998 there were multiple Internet IPOs seemingly every week. In the fall of that year a San Francisco outfit called The Globe, a too-early social network created by a couple of Cornell students, established the precedent that a company need not have much of a business at all to convince IPO investors of its value, only a little Internet sizzle. The company had posted a loss of $11.5 million for the first nine months of the year on sales of $2.7 million, but after its IPO it was somehow worth more than $800 million.

—p.71 The Bible of the Dot-com Boom (67) by Jonathan Weber 27 minutes ago
75

Trevor Traina’s startup was a more typical case, even if his status as a child of San Francisco’s old-money royalty made him an outlier among the city’s dot-com entrepreneurs. His father, John Traina, was a shipping executive and a suave, handsome man-about-town, known for his conversational charm and his Fabergé egg collection, and for his marriages. His mother Dede was an heir to the Dow Chemical fortune and an active philanthropist, serving for many years as the chair of the de Young Museum. Now his father was married to the romance novelist Danielle Steel, with whom he had five children, and his mother had tied the knot with real estate investor John Wilsey. It was all as blue-blooded as it gets in San Francisco.

Trevor Traina had an MBA, and in 1996 he raised $350,000 in seed money from friends and family for an Internet venture: a product-lookup website, inspired by Traina’s frustration when trying to find an obscure electronic product at the big Circuit City store on Van Ness Avenue. The startup moved into offices at China Basin Landing and seemed to be getting some traction, but by the next year the company needed more money, and it wasn’t going well. “We went to the consumer electronics show and we got a bunch of commitments from companies like Sony and Samsung. And I was like, wow, we’re really off to the races here,” he recounted later. “And for the next few months I followed up diligently with all those big electronics companies, and not one of them followed up.”

He’d been working nonstop, desperately trying to raise new financing. “I had called dozens and dozens of VCs, pitched everyone I could think of,” he said. “I went to every Industry Standard party, kissed every butt.” Finally he got a nibble from a hot VC of the moment, Ann Winblad, one of the rare women in the business, who’d built a successful new firm with partner John Hummer. An up-and-coming junior associate, Bill Gurley, was assigned to put together a deal, but it wasn’t a pretty one for Traina. “I would have basically had to sell out every one of my friends and family. It was a deal with the devil I couldn’t do, and I distinctly remember sitting in my car and crying. I was gonna lose everyone their money, my grandmother, my parents. We were just completely SOL.” Then, through a stroke of luck, he ended up on the cover of Business 2.0 magazine, which led to some introductions that eventually led to the sale of the company to Microsoft, for $100 million in very liquid stock. The fast-inflating bubble could change fortunes in an instant; Traina would go on to do several more startups and eventually be named ambassador to Austria during the first presidency of Donald Trump.

lolll

—p.75 The Bible of the Dot-com Boom (67) by Jonathan Weber 21 minutes ago

Trevor Traina’s startup was a more typical case, even if his status as a child of San Francisco’s old-money royalty made him an outlier among the city’s dot-com entrepreneurs. His father, John Traina, was a shipping executive and a suave, handsome man-about-town, known for his conversational charm and his Fabergé egg collection, and for his marriages. His mother Dede was an heir to the Dow Chemical fortune and an active philanthropist, serving for many years as the chair of the de Young Museum. Now his father was married to the romance novelist Danielle Steel, with whom he had five children, and his mother had tied the knot with real estate investor John Wilsey. It was all as blue-blooded as it gets in San Francisco.

Trevor Traina had an MBA, and in 1996 he raised $350,000 in seed money from friends and family for an Internet venture: a product-lookup website, inspired by Traina’s frustration when trying to find an obscure electronic product at the big Circuit City store on Van Ness Avenue. The startup moved into offices at China Basin Landing and seemed to be getting some traction, but by the next year the company needed more money, and it wasn’t going well. “We went to the consumer electronics show and we got a bunch of commitments from companies like Sony and Samsung. And I was like, wow, we’re really off to the races here,” he recounted later. “And for the next few months I followed up diligently with all those big electronics companies, and not one of them followed up.”

He’d been working nonstop, desperately trying to raise new financing. “I had called dozens and dozens of VCs, pitched everyone I could think of,” he said. “I went to every Industry Standard party, kissed every butt.” Finally he got a nibble from a hot VC of the moment, Ann Winblad, one of the rare women in the business, who’d built a successful new firm with partner John Hummer. An up-and-coming junior associate, Bill Gurley, was assigned to put together a deal, but it wasn’t a pretty one for Traina. “I would have basically had to sell out every one of my friends and family. It was a deal with the devil I couldn’t do, and I distinctly remember sitting in my car and crying. I was gonna lose everyone their money, my grandmother, my parents. We were just completely SOL.” Then, through a stroke of luck, he ended up on the cover of Business 2.0 magazine, which led to some introductions that eventually led to the sale of the company to Microsoft, for $100 million in very liquid stock. The fast-inflating bubble could change fortunes in an instant; Traina would go on to do several more startups and eventually be named ambassador to Austria during the first presidency of Donald Trump.

lolll

—p.75 The Bible of the Dot-com Boom (67) by Jonathan Weber 21 minutes ago