The San Francisco Internet industry had failed on the vision front too. The change-the-world mantra and the counterculture-infused ideals of a New Economy workplace that was less hierarchical, more freewheeling and more fun had been revealed as empty promises. Companies like Twitter, Salesforce, Lyft, Airbnb, as they got bigger, also got more conventional in their pursuit of financial interests above all else. Corporate support for local political priorities such as diversity and defense of immigrants, and workplace cultures that fostered employee empowerment and flexible lifestyles, had once looked like a new “stakeholder capitalism” paradigm in the making and a victory for the values of the early Internet. Instead, such policies turned out to be entirely situational, at least at the bigger companies, emerging not from any belief system but rather a simple desire to placate restive employees at a moment when good people were hard to find. Corporate efforts to help the city, such as the community benefit agreements that were part of the Twitter tax break, or Marc Benioff’s support of the Prop C homelessness initiative, proved to be the exceptions and not the rule.
In another era, companies like Stripe and Coinbase that had thousands of local employees might have been part of something like the old Committee on Jobs, where big businesses worked with the city in a way that went beyond lobbying for their own interests. Instead, two of the most successful startups in city history grew resentful of the extra costs and hassles of doing business in San Francisco, and the hostile attitude of the local left, and moved their headquarters out of town. Internet companies were less tied to the city than their old-economy forbearers; top executives and investors, with their multiple homes and private jets, especially so.