For the right, San Francisco is exhibit number one for the argument that progressive policies on crime and drugs have ruined Democratic-run cities. Among moderate Democrats, San Francisco is a great example of the failures of anti-growth liberalism, as outlined in the “abundance” theory popularized by journalists Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson. The progressive left has its diagnosis too: If only the tech companies and the billionaires weren’t so greedy, there’d be plenty of resources to solve social problems like homelessness.
There is certainly some truth in each of these. Yet as I revisited the remarkable history of the past three decades and interviewed more than two hundred people at the center of events, I found that none of the pat explanations really captured what had happened in San Francisco. The deeper story, in my view, is only partly about the various ways that city government fumbled the ball, or that the tech industry’s heedlessness created needless strife. It’s also about how the intensifying forces of techno-capitalism operate by their own logic. Considering the city and its tech industry as protagonists in a wider drama leads to more nuanced and richer interpretations.
ok boomer