Larry Ellison’s sporting interests weren’t limited to the Warriors. He was an accomplished sailor and had spent many millions competing in the America’s Cup, one of the sporting world’s oldest and oddest events, finally winning the trophy in 2009. The cup-holder had the right to choose the venue for the next regatta, and since San Francisco Bay is a celebrated sailing venue, the city was the obvious choice for Ellison. Hoping to generate fresh interest in a sport that was rather boring to watch, his team came up with a radical new specification: seventy-two-foot catamarans, equipped with rigid “wing” sails, that would rise up out of the water on narrow metal hydrofoils, reaching speeds of more than fifty miles an hour. It was impressively high-tech and held the potential for much more exciting races.
Ellison, though, thought the city should subsidize the event, as previous venues like Newport, Rhode Island, and Valencia, Spain, had done. But unlike those pleasant but out-of-the-way places, San Francisco didn’t need the money and the media attention that the races would bring, and nobody could understand why Ellison wouldn’t pay for his own party. The city eventually agreed to put up about $40 million for infrastructure and services, to be raised from private sources. The fundraising task fell to philanthropist and former city official Mark Buell. It wasn’t much fun.
lmao
Larry Ellison’s sporting interests weren’t limited to the Warriors. He was an accomplished sailor and had spent many millions competing in the America’s Cup, one of the sporting world’s oldest and oddest events, finally winning the trophy in 2009. The cup-holder had the right to choose the venue for the next regatta, and since San Francisco Bay is a celebrated sailing venue, the city was the obvious choice for Ellison. Hoping to generate fresh interest in a sport that was rather boring to watch, his team came up with a radical new specification: seventy-two-foot catamarans, equipped with rigid “wing” sails, that would rise up out of the water on narrow metal hydrofoils, reaching speeds of more than fifty miles an hour. It was impressively high-tech and held the potential for much more exciting races.
Ellison, though, thought the city should subsidize the event, as previous venues like Newport, Rhode Island, and Valencia, Spain, had done. But unlike those pleasant but out-of-the-way places, San Francisco didn’t need the money and the media attention that the races would bring, and nobody could understand why Ellison wouldn’t pay for his own party. The city eventually agreed to put up about $40 million for infrastructure and services, to be raised from private sources. The fundraising task fell to philanthropist and former city official Mark Buell. It wasn’t much fun.
lmao
The gaudy excess of the America’s Cup was fitting for a moment in US history where the rich were getting richer very fast, and pushing income inequality to a level not seen in a century. There would be plenty more extravagance: Sean Parker spent $4.5 million in 2014 on a medieval-themed wedding, held in a redwood grove in Big Sur bedecked with three hundred thousand flower petals, faux stone walls, a specially built bridge and erstwhile castle ruins. He was pilloried on social media for allegedly lacking a permit and damaging the redwood forest and ended up paying a fine, though he was livid about being cast as a bad person and insisted he’d done everything by the book. Inviting magazine photographers to the over-the-top event was perhaps not his best move.
The gaudy excess of the America’s Cup was fitting for a moment in US history where the rich were getting richer very fast, and pushing income inequality to a level not seen in a century. There would be plenty more extravagance: Sean Parker spent $4.5 million in 2014 on a medieval-themed wedding, held in a redwood grove in Big Sur bedecked with three hundred thousand flower petals, faux stone walls, a specially built bridge and erstwhile castle ruins. He was pilloried on social media for allegedly lacking a permit and damaging the redwood forest and ended up paying a fine, though he was livid about being cast as a bad person and insisted he’d done everything by the book. Inviting magazine photographers to the over-the-top event was perhaps not his best move.
A camp called Caravancycle had pushed the line on commercialization, marketing an all-inclusive experience for up to $20,000 where fancy meals, air-conditioned RVs, showers and private toilets were all provided, and wristbands were required to get in. David Rodriguez, a veteran Burner from San Francisco, thought it was all a little much. “This whole thing that you can pay a bunch of money and they’re going to take care of you, that was against all of our ideas of Burning Man,” he recounted. He and friends began brainstorming about maybe showing up outside as peasants with pitchforks. Eventually they came up with a plan: A group of six would dress up as maids and butlers and pretend they were employees.
“We lined up in formation and walked right in,” recalled Suzannah Cowell, another participant. She had a brush, and set about cleaning people’s boots, while another “maid” offered a refreshing spritzer. One “butler” had a beard brush, and others had dusters, and they made a show of giving people “service.” “Oh my god, Jonny needs some service over here,” Cowell playacted, and a couple of people would rush over. It went on for a while, and the attitudes of the recipients varied. One person muttered, “About time we got some service here,” but mostly people took it with pleasure, with only a few suspecting a joke. Finally as they were leaving, someone approached and said, “Do you work here?” “We said no, and we told him, and he thought it was hilarious.”
The Burning Man Project would later ban the practice of selling package tours or paying anyone to work at the event. It would eventually insist that RVs had to be driven into Black Rock City by whoever would be using them. It was all hard to enforce, though, and some of the policies were later eased. Conley didn’t think fancy camps should be banned, but he acknowledged the tensions and how the event was evolving.
lmao
A camp called Caravancycle had pushed the line on commercialization, marketing an all-inclusive experience for up to $20,000 where fancy meals, air-conditioned RVs, showers and private toilets were all provided, and wristbands were required to get in. David Rodriguez, a veteran Burner from San Francisco, thought it was all a little much. “This whole thing that you can pay a bunch of money and they’re going to take care of you, that was against all of our ideas of Burning Man,” he recounted. He and friends began brainstorming about maybe showing up outside as peasants with pitchforks. Eventually they came up with a plan: A group of six would dress up as maids and butlers and pretend they were employees.
“We lined up in formation and walked right in,” recalled Suzannah Cowell, another participant. She had a brush, and set about cleaning people’s boots, while another “maid” offered a refreshing spritzer. One “butler” had a beard brush, and others had dusters, and they made a show of giving people “service.” “Oh my god, Jonny needs some service over here,” Cowell playacted, and a couple of people would rush over. It went on for a while, and the attitudes of the recipients varied. One person muttered, “About time we got some service here,” but mostly people took it with pleasure, with only a few suspecting a joke. Finally as they were leaving, someone approached and said, “Do you work here?” “We said no, and we told him, and he thought it was hilarious.”
The Burning Man Project would later ban the practice of selling package tours or paying anyone to work at the event. It would eventually insist that RVs had to be driven into Black Rock City by whoever would be using them. It was all hard to enforce, though, and some of the policies were later eased. Conley didn’t think fancy camps should be banned, but he acknowledged the tensions and how the event was evolving.
lmao
“I used to scoff at this idea that we’re a movement, like that’s such bullshit,” said Candace Locklear, the PR pro who’d volunteered to wrangle the media in the early days. “Turns out, it’s a global movement. It really is. The principles have inspired a ton of other events and festivals, so I think the vision was awesome.” As for the corrupting influence of the money, she was on Larry Harvey’s side. “When the billionaires started coming, the old school was like, ‘Why are you letting them in, why do we have to have the one percent at our event?’ And he would say, ‘If five percent of our playa dust rubs off on them, then you have done something good to change their mind or open their mind to another way of life.’ ”
lol
“I used to scoff at this idea that we’re a movement, like that’s such bullshit,” said Candace Locklear, the PR pro who’d volunteered to wrangle the media in the early days. “Turns out, it’s a global movement. It really is. The principles have inspired a ton of other events and festivals, so I think the vision was awesome.” As for the corrupting influence of the money, she was on Larry Harvey’s side. “When the billionaires started coming, the old school was like, ‘Why are you letting them in, why do we have to have the one percent at our event?’ And he would say, ‘If five percent of our playa dust rubs off on them, then you have done something good to change their mind or open their mind to another way of life.’ ”
lol
Chris Larsen’s Prosper, the lending platform he launched in 2008 after selling E-Loan, had been a failure: The timing was bad, coming as it did in the teeth of the Great Recession, and the social dynamics of lending and repayment didn’t work as anticipated. Now crypto looked like the next turn of the wheel, and in 2012 Larsen joined with two Canadian cryptographers who’d launched a company called OpenCoin, later changing the name to Ripple. The goal was to build a better system for banks to exchange funds based on the Ripple crypto token, known as XRP. By the middle of the decade the company had signed up some big international banks to try it out.
A lot of other entrepreneurs were also eyeing crypto. At first, Larsen said later, the main concern was a simple one: “Everyone is like, this is legal, right?” A turning point came in 2013, when the Federal Reserve signaled that it wouldn’t simply shut the new industry down. Ross Ulbricht’s arrest that year was in some ways part and parcel of crypto winning respectability: If Bitcoin was to become part of the global financial system, it wouldn’t be a good look if it were mainly used by drug dealers.
Larsen called 2013 the “magic year” when crypto came into its own, with San Francisco as its capital. An online crypto brokerage called Coinbase, the brainchild of former Airbnb engineer Brian Armstrong, had launched in the city in 2012, fresh out of Y Combinator. The price of Bitcoin, still in the double-digits at the end of 2012, would spike to over $1,000 by the end of the year before falling back.
sigh
Chris Larsen’s Prosper, the lending platform he launched in 2008 after selling E-Loan, had been a failure: The timing was bad, coming as it did in the teeth of the Great Recession, and the social dynamics of lending and repayment didn’t work as anticipated. Now crypto looked like the next turn of the wheel, and in 2012 Larsen joined with two Canadian cryptographers who’d launched a company called OpenCoin, later changing the name to Ripple. The goal was to build a better system for banks to exchange funds based on the Ripple crypto token, known as XRP. By the middle of the decade the company had signed up some big international banks to try it out.
A lot of other entrepreneurs were also eyeing crypto. At first, Larsen said later, the main concern was a simple one: “Everyone is like, this is legal, right?” A turning point came in 2013, when the Federal Reserve signaled that it wouldn’t simply shut the new industry down. Ross Ulbricht’s arrest that year was in some ways part and parcel of crypto winning respectability: If Bitcoin was to become part of the global financial system, it wouldn’t be a good look if it were mainly used by drug dealers.
Larsen called 2013 the “magic year” when crypto came into its own, with San Francisco as its capital. An online crypto brokerage called Coinbase, the brainchild of former Airbnb engineer Brian Armstrong, had launched in the city in 2012, fresh out of Y Combinator. The price of Bitcoin, still in the double-digits at the end of 2012, would spike to over $1,000 by the end of the year before falling back.
sigh
Even Mark Zuckerberg now wanted to live there, or at least have a pied-à-terre. In the fall of 2012 he plunked down about $10 million for a house in the hilly, upscale western edge of the neighborhood, an area called Dolores Heights. He apparently wanted that place in particular—the real estate site Zillow estimated its value at just $3.2 million—and the price set a record for the Mission. He quickly launched a massive renovation that would take more than two years, ultimately yielding a nearly eight thousand-square-foot dwelling whose amenities included a giant turntable in the newly dug garage, so cars wouldn’t have to turn around. Critics dubbed it Fort Zuckerberg for all the security measures, which to the great annoyance of neighbors often included two big black SUVs idling at the curb.
The Facebook CEO and his wife, Priscilla Chan, moved in in 2015, though it was never entirely clear how much time they spent there. They also had a compound in Palo Alto, where they had bought out all the surrounding homes, and were starting to accumulate real estate in Hawaii. The Mission, though, had become the heart of the burgeoning tech scene—and a dramatic representation of how the city was changing.
lol
Even Mark Zuckerberg now wanted to live there, or at least have a pied-à-terre. In the fall of 2012 he plunked down about $10 million for a house in the hilly, upscale western edge of the neighborhood, an area called Dolores Heights. He apparently wanted that place in particular—the real estate site Zillow estimated its value at just $3.2 million—and the price set a record for the Mission. He quickly launched a massive renovation that would take more than two years, ultimately yielding a nearly eight thousand-square-foot dwelling whose amenities included a giant turntable in the newly dug garage, so cars wouldn’t have to turn around. Critics dubbed it Fort Zuckerberg for all the security measures, which to the great annoyance of neighbors often included two big black SUVs idling at the curb.
The Facebook CEO and his wife, Priscilla Chan, moved in in 2015, though it was never entirely clear how much time they spent there. They also had a compound in Palo Alto, where they had bought out all the surrounding homes, and were starting to accumulate real estate in Hawaii. The Mission, though, had become the heart of the burgeoning tech scene—and a dramatic representation of how the city was changing.
lol
The companies also agreed to work with the MTA on routes and schedules, and many buses were shifted to bigger streets with stops further apart—changes Gillett attributes in part to the city’s transit union, which didn’t like the impingement on its turf. The unions in fact had successfully used the ruckus to organize the shuttle drivers and persuade the tech companies to go along with unionization, rather than find cheaper non-union operators—a key dynamic in forging the agreement with the city. Paine, the MTA staffer who Gillett had worked with, then led a big study on how it was all working, with MTA inspectors counting buses and passengers around the city, tracking Muni delays and categorizing complaints.
nice
The companies also agreed to work with the MTA on routes and schedules, and many buses were shifted to bigger streets with stops further apart—changes Gillett attributes in part to the city’s transit union, which didn’t like the impingement on its turf. The unions in fact had successfully used the ruckus to organize the shuttle drivers and persuade the tech companies to go along with unionization, rather than find cheaper non-union operators—a key dynamic in forging the agreement with the city. Paine, the MTA staffer who Gillett had worked with, then led a big study on how it was all working, with MTA inspectors counting buses and passengers around the city, tracking Muni delays and categorizing complaints.
nice
Gordon Knox, who’d take over as president of SFAI in 2017, said many wealthy tech people brought a venture-capital perspective to philanthropy that wasn’t helpful at all. “They’re totally happy with the idea of losing scores of millions of dollars in scores of different enterprises, because if one in twenty works out, that’s great. But as soon as you tell them it’s actually for philanthropy—i.e., there is no return, this is money to help the community—then it’s like, ‘We don’t do that.’ The tech money is just so wildly un-philanthropic.”
That sentiment was a common refrain in the city’s philanthropic circles; it was easy to see from the donor lists that the bulk of support for art came from the city’s old-money families. There were of course exceptions: The Minnesota Street Project, an ambitious contemporary art center in Dogpatch, was underwritten by tech investor Andy Rappaport. Matt Mullenweg, the WordPress founder, would become a patron of Ana Teresa Fernández and several other artists, and open a jazz club in North Beach (in addition to having backed the Bay Lights project). Williams was spending money too. And support for the arts wasn’t always a fair measure of generosity: Marc Benioff, for one, had given heavily to schools and hospitals. Michael Moritz’s Crankstart Foundation would become one of the city’s largest philanthropies and a major supporter of social services programs.
oh great michael moritz is cool now
Gordon Knox, who’d take over as president of SFAI in 2017, said many wealthy tech people brought a venture-capital perspective to philanthropy that wasn’t helpful at all. “They’re totally happy with the idea of losing scores of millions of dollars in scores of different enterprises, because if one in twenty works out, that’s great. But as soon as you tell them it’s actually for philanthropy—i.e., there is no return, this is money to help the community—then it’s like, ‘We don’t do that.’ The tech money is just so wildly un-philanthropic.”
That sentiment was a common refrain in the city’s philanthropic circles; it was easy to see from the donor lists that the bulk of support for art came from the city’s old-money families. There were of course exceptions: The Minnesota Street Project, an ambitious contemporary art center in Dogpatch, was underwritten by tech investor Andy Rappaport. Matt Mullenweg, the WordPress founder, would become a patron of Ana Teresa Fernández and several other artists, and open a jazz club in North Beach (in addition to having backed the Bay Lights project). Williams was spending money too. And support for the arts wasn’t always a fair measure of generosity: Marc Benioff, for one, had given heavily to schools and hospitals. Michael Moritz’s Crankstart Foundation would become one of the city’s largest philanthropies and a major supporter of social services programs.
oh great michael moritz is cool now
Airbnb was by then facing blowback in many cities, and ramping up a high-powered PR and lobbying operation. Ron Conway, the unlikely kingmaker and now self-appointed champion for all San Francisco tech startups, was getting seriously dialed into the local network of political consultants, many of them former City Hall officials, who knew people and could make things happen. This was the deep City Family, one might say, talented operatives working behind the scenes at firms like Barbary Coast Consulting, Ground Floor Public Affairs and Platinum Advisors. They didn’t come particularly cheap, but then again, their fees were puny next to what was at stake for the companies, which in some cases had little future if regulations went the wrong way. Y Combinator didn’t teach you what to do when your startup got crosswise with local laws and city officials, and San Francisco was a crucial test case.
Airbnb was by then facing blowback in many cities, and ramping up a high-powered PR and lobbying operation. Ron Conway, the unlikely kingmaker and now self-appointed champion for all San Francisco tech startups, was getting seriously dialed into the local network of political consultants, many of them former City Hall officials, who knew people and could make things happen. This was the deep City Family, one might say, talented operatives working behind the scenes at firms like Barbary Coast Consulting, Ground Floor Public Affairs and Platinum Advisors. They didn’t come particularly cheap, but then again, their fees were puny next to what was at stake for the companies, which in some cases had little future if regulations went the wrong way. Y Combinator didn’t teach you what to do when your startup got crosswise with local laws and city officials, and San Francisco was a crucial test case.
“They were freaking out,” Lehane recounted later. “I did a lot of ballot work in California, statewide ballots primarily, and I said, ‘Look, you’re on the “no” side of the ballot. The typical way you win these ballots is, you spend a bunch of money, and the no side wins eighty percent of these. There’s a pretty tried-and-true way to do these things.’ ” But Chesky wanted to see if there was a different approach. “Is there a way we can think about using this as an opportunity to rally and organize our host community and our users, our guests,” Chesky asked, according to Lehane. That conversation eventually led to the creation of the first home-sharing club. “We organized the hosts. We communicated with the guests. We had hosts who were precinct captains and going to their neighbors. When we started off, we were close to twenty points behind. We ran a pretty strong narrative that talked about the economic benefits that the city and in particular these hosts were getting. That became the template for the campaigns we started to run around the world.”
Such organizing would be an important dynamic in regulatory battles not just for Airbnb but for Uber, Lyft and other companies in what was sometimes known as the sharing economy. It’s not clear how big a difference it ultimately made in San Francisco, though. The company had also employed Lehane’s tried-and-true approach, spending more than $8 million to beat back the measure—an astonishing sum in a small city, amounting to $75 for every “no” vote. It lost by 55–45 percent. Whatever one might think about the merits of the issue, it was certainly a demonstration of the new Internet industry’s political and financial muscle.
a ballot measure led by calvin welch for banning airbnbs for < 30 days
“They were freaking out,” Lehane recounted later. “I did a lot of ballot work in California, statewide ballots primarily, and I said, ‘Look, you’re on the “no” side of the ballot. The typical way you win these ballots is, you spend a bunch of money, and the no side wins eighty percent of these. There’s a pretty tried-and-true way to do these things.’ ” But Chesky wanted to see if there was a different approach. “Is there a way we can think about using this as an opportunity to rally and organize our host community and our users, our guests,” Chesky asked, according to Lehane. That conversation eventually led to the creation of the first home-sharing club. “We organized the hosts. We communicated with the guests. We had hosts who were precinct captains and going to their neighbors. When we started off, we were close to twenty points behind. We ran a pretty strong narrative that talked about the economic benefits that the city and in particular these hosts were getting. That became the template for the campaigns we started to run around the world.”
Such organizing would be an important dynamic in regulatory battles not just for Airbnb but for Uber, Lyft and other companies in what was sometimes known as the sharing economy. It’s not clear how big a difference it ultimately made in San Francisco, though. The company had also employed Lehane’s tried-and-true approach, spending more than $8 million to beat back the measure—an astonishing sum in a small city, amounting to $75 for every “no” vote. It lost by 55–45 percent. Whatever one might think about the merits of the issue, it was certainly a demonstration of the new Internet industry’s political and financial muscle.
a ballot measure led by calvin welch for banning airbnbs for < 30 days