Mark Pincus’s game company, Zynga, was blowing up, and it was on a path to an IPO too. It had just moved into its new home in the SoMa neighborhood known as Showplace Square, but it was outside the tax-break district, and Zynga leadership hadn’t been aware of how the city’s payroll tax would hit an IPO. Costolo says it was Twitter’s finance team that alerted Zynga to the issue, and though Pincus doesn’t recall that detail, he does remember his indignation in learning about it. Between the IPO and the regular payroll tax levy, Zynga looked to be on the hook for $80 million in city taxes, he says, and the company’s CFO was soon raising the relocation issue with the Board. “He’s like, ‘Here are some headquarters options, because we’re definitely not going to pay the $80 million,’ ” Pincus said later. He thought the payroll tax was outrageous. And like many tech CEOs, he was offended by the attitude behind it. “There’s a cultural thing that’s getting lost here,” Pincus said. “Politicians should want you here.” Certainly Pincus’s own vision for San Francisco was a business-friendly one, with entrepreneurship and economic growth at the heart of it.
Pincus then did what you have to do when you have a problem with San Francisco’s government: He hired a lobbyist. It turned out a lot of people in the business community were unhappy that the Twitter tax break offered relief only for companies in a specific part of town. Soon the Board of Supervisors was considering another piece of legislation that would eliminate the payroll tax on IPO proceeds for all companies. Pincus’s lobbyist, Chris Gruwell, told him the swing vote on the Board was the idiosyncratic Green Party supervisor Ross Mirkarimi, and the way to get to him was through the hotel workers’ union. So Pincus took some meetings, including one with the service employees’ union boss, a famously tough character named Olga Miranda.
Mirkarimi came around, and just a couple of months after approving the Twitter tax break, and with far less fanfare, the Board of Supervisors passed the IPO tax-relief bill. The Twitter tax break was attacked for years as a giveaway to the tech industry, but this second step would be a much bigger hit to city tax revenues.
lol
Mark Pincus’s game company, Zynga, was blowing up, and it was on a path to an IPO too. It had just moved into its new home in the SoMa neighborhood known as Showplace Square, but it was outside the tax-break district, and Zynga leadership hadn’t been aware of how the city’s payroll tax would hit an IPO. Costolo says it was Twitter’s finance team that alerted Zynga to the issue, and though Pincus doesn’t recall that detail, he does remember his indignation in learning about it. Between the IPO and the regular payroll tax levy, Zynga looked to be on the hook for $80 million in city taxes, he says, and the company’s CFO was soon raising the relocation issue with the Board. “He’s like, ‘Here are some headquarters options, because we’re definitely not going to pay the $80 million,’ ” Pincus said later. He thought the payroll tax was outrageous. And like many tech CEOs, he was offended by the attitude behind it. “There’s a cultural thing that’s getting lost here,” Pincus said. “Politicians should want you here.” Certainly Pincus’s own vision for San Francisco was a business-friendly one, with entrepreneurship and economic growth at the heart of it.
Pincus then did what you have to do when you have a problem with San Francisco’s government: He hired a lobbyist. It turned out a lot of people in the business community were unhappy that the Twitter tax break offered relief only for companies in a specific part of town. Soon the Board of Supervisors was considering another piece of legislation that would eliminate the payroll tax on IPO proceeds for all companies. Pincus’s lobbyist, Chris Gruwell, told him the swing vote on the Board was the idiosyncratic Green Party supervisor Ross Mirkarimi, and the way to get to him was through the hotel workers’ union. So Pincus took some meetings, including one with the service employees’ union boss, a famously tough character named Olga Miranda.
Mirkarimi came around, and just a couple of months after approving the Twitter tax break, and with far less fanfare, the Board of Supervisors passed the IPO tax-relief bill. The Twitter tax break was attacked for years as a giveaway to the tech industry, but this second step would be a much bigger hit to city tax revenues.
lol
Conway put together a new lobbying group, called SF.Citi. “Technology companies needed to take a ‘One City’ approach and build a shared sense of community and civic responsibility in San Francisco,” he declared later in describing the purpose of the new organization. The group would back efforts like a “clean streets” initiative where tech company employees would volunteer to pick up trash, and Conway by all appearances was sincere in exhorting his companies to “give back.” SF.Citi’s first task, though, was less high-minded: assuring the passage of a 2012 business tax overhaul, which benefited the tech industry at the expense of old-economy companies. The Chamber of Commerce, and other business lobbying groups like Advance SF, were dominated by banks and hotels and real estate interests, alongside perennial power player PG&E. They didn’t like the tax changes, which replaced the payroll tax with a so-called gross receipts tax, nor were they interested in playing second fiddle to the likes of Ron Conway. Some of them could see pretty clearly that for their own businesses, the Internet economy was a mixed blessing at best.
Conway put together a new lobbying group, called SF.Citi. “Technology companies needed to take a ‘One City’ approach and build a shared sense of community and civic responsibility in San Francisco,” he declared later in describing the purpose of the new organization. The group would back efforts like a “clean streets” initiative where tech company employees would volunteer to pick up trash, and Conway by all appearances was sincere in exhorting his companies to “give back.” SF.Citi’s first task, though, was less high-minded: assuring the passage of a 2012 business tax overhaul, which benefited the tech industry at the expense of old-economy companies. The Chamber of Commerce, and other business lobbying groups like Advance SF, were dominated by banks and hotels and real estate interests, alongside perennial power player PG&E. They didn’t like the tax changes, which replaced the payroll tax with a so-called gross receipts tax, nor were they interested in playing second fiddle to the likes of Ron Conway. Some of them could see pretty clearly that for their own businesses, the Internet economy was a mixed blessing at best.
Lee and other city officials continued to correct anyone who would listen that it was not the “Twitter tax break” but rather the “Central Market/Tenderloin Payroll Tax Exclusion,” and sure enough, there was a flurry of new companies moving to take advantage. One Kings Lane, a luxury goods retailer founded by Mark Pincus’s then-wife, Allie, moved into the Twitter building. A social network for businesses called Yammer, led by PayPal mafia alumnus and future Donald Trump acolyte David Sacks, would take the whole third floor. Zendesk, a Danish customer service startup that had moved to the city in 2008, rented a historic building at 989 Market Street, mainly for the bargain-basement rent of just $5 a square foot—less than a tenth of the prices downtown. Happily for the city, Zendesk brought its Scandinavian social justice values to the challenge of revitalizing Mid-Market, and would be the first to implement a community benefits agreement.
“All of us at Zendesk are proud to be citizens of a city that has the vision and ability to execute on making San Francisco a better place to live and work,” CEO Mikkel Svane enthused.
this is so long 2010s lmao rip
Lee and other city officials continued to correct anyone who would listen that it was not the “Twitter tax break” but rather the “Central Market/Tenderloin Payroll Tax Exclusion,” and sure enough, there was a flurry of new companies moving to take advantage. One Kings Lane, a luxury goods retailer founded by Mark Pincus’s then-wife, Allie, moved into the Twitter building. A social network for businesses called Yammer, led by PayPal mafia alumnus and future Donald Trump acolyte David Sacks, would take the whole third floor. Zendesk, a Danish customer service startup that had moved to the city in 2008, rented a historic building at 989 Market Street, mainly for the bargain-basement rent of just $5 a square foot—less than a tenth of the prices downtown. Happily for the city, Zendesk brought its Scandinavian social justice values to the challenge of revitalizing Mid-Market, and would be the first to implement a community benefits agreement.
“All of us at Zendesk are proud to be citizens of a city that has the vision and ability to execute on making San Francisco a better place to live and work,” CEO Mikkel Svane enthused.
this is so long 2010s lmao rip