Craig Newmark had been laid off from Schwab in 1995 but was making good money as a freelance programmer, and his passion project, Craigs-list, kept growing. People were now offering to pay for job listings, and in 1998 he started sporadically charging for help-wanted advertisements and took on some volunteers to help him keep it all running. He was a one-man show still, writing new software to make things simpler and faster, and paying a lot of attention to customer service. “The lesson I learned is, keep things as simple as possible, and then people won’t need much help,” he said later. “That worked out pretty well, right?”
By 1999, he realized Craigslist had to be a proper business; he’d been paying himself only occasionally and relying on volunteers, but that wasn’t working anymore. He needed to hire people, and he needed a business plan. “At that point, VCs and bankers wanted me to do the usual Silicon Valley thing, to monetize heavily, and then they’d throw billions at me,” he said later. But “monetize heavily” meant junking up the site with ads, or charging lots of fees, or selling names to others, and Newmark just didn’t want to do it. It was a community service, there to help people, and it didn’t cost much to run. “I began to remember a lesson that I internalized from Sunday school back at the Jewish Community Center in Morristown, New Jersey: know when enough is enough,” he says. Refusing the VC money was an exceedingly rare choice, but Newmark never wavered, and he’d ultimately do extraordinarily well without it.
<3
Craig Newmark had been laid off from Schwab in 1995 but was making good money as a freelance programmer, and his passion project, Craigs-list, kept growing. People were now offering to pay for job listings, and in 1998 he started sporadically charging for help-wanted advertisements and took on some volunteers to help him keep it all running. He was a one-man show still, writing new software to make things simpler and faster, and paying a lot of attention to customer service. “The lesson I learned is, keep things as simple as possible, and then people won’t need much help,” he said later. “That worked out pretty well, right?”
By 1999, he realized Craigslist had to be a proper business; he’d been paying himself only occasionally and relying on volunteers, but that wasn’t working anymore. He needed to hire people, and he needed a business plan. “At that point, VCs and bankers wanted me to do the usual Silicon Valley thing, to monetize heavily, and then they’d throw billions at me,” he said later. But “monetize heavily” meant junking up the site with ads, or charging lots of fees, or selling names to others, and Newmark just didn’t want to do it. It was a community service, there to help people, and it didn’t cost much to run. “I began to remember a lesson that I internalized from Sunday school back at the Jewish Community Center in Morristown, New Jersey: know when enough is enough,” he says. Refusing the VC money was an exceedingly rare choice, but Newmark never wavered, and he’d ultimately do extraordinarily well without it.
<3
Chris Carlsson, a flinty writer and activist who was an important instigator in the city’s protest culture, shared the Cacophonist’s interest in adventuresome public stunts and the critique of capitalism, but he inverted their priorities.
“Why don’t we do something political with bikes?” Carlsson had said one day in 1992, amid the haze of marijuana smoke at the offices of Typesetting Etc., a disheveled two-room suite on the second floor of the old Grant Building, on Market and Sixth Street. Carlsson and his business partner, a talented illustrator named Jim Swanson, provided typesetting services—the main clients were a couple of union newspapers—and made about half their money on the “etc.” part of the business—namely, selling weed. There were often people hanging around, bike messengers and temp workers and miscellaneous others who came by to score. It was a clubhouse for the disaffected office workers and pranksters who, along with Carlsson and Swanson, had created the magazine Processed World, an arch satire of life in the corporate maze that came out irregularly for almost two decades beginning in the early 1980s.
awww
Chris Carlsson, a flinty writer and activist who was an important instigator in the city’s protest culture, shared the Cacophonist’s interest in adventuresome public stunts and the critique of capitalism, but he inverted their priorities.
“Why don’t we do something political with bikes?” Carlsson had said one day in 1992, amid the haze of marijuana smoke at the offices of Typesetting Etc., a disheveled two-room suite on the second floor of the old Grant Building, on Market and Sixth Street. Carlsson and his business partner, a talented illustrator named Jim Swanson, provided typesetting services—the main clients were a couple of union newspapers—and made about half their money on the “etc.” part of the business—namely, selling weed. There were often people hanging around, bike messengers and temp workers and miscellaneous others who came by to score. It was a clubhouse for the disaffected office workers and pranksters who, along with Carlsson and Swanson, had created the magazine Processed World, an arch satire of life in the corporate maze that came out irregularly for almost two decades beginning in the early 1980s.
awww
It was Processed World that would first publish the “manifesto” of Law’s Billboard Liberation Front, conceived as a parody—“through the Ad and the intent of the Advertiser we form our ideas and learn the myths that make us into what we are as a people.” The magazine was often produced on paper stolen from offices, and then distributed in the financial district by costumed anti-corporate warriors. It represented the more traditional left-wing view of technology as a tool of corporate and government repression, rather than personal liberation.
hell yeah
It was Processed World that would first publish the “manifesto” of Law’s Billboard Liberation Front, conceived as a parody—“through the Ad and the intent of the Advertiser we form our ideas and learn the myths that make us into what we are as a people.” The magazine was often produced on paper stolen from offices, and then distributed in the financial district by costumed anti-corporate warriors. It represented the more traditional left-wing view of technology as a tool of corporate and government repression, rather than personal liberation.
hell yeah
But if he wasn’t always anti-tech, Carlsson was most definitely an anti-capitalist. He’d grown up in North Oakland, and a high school gig caddying at the exclusive Claremont Country Club was a formative experience: His fellow caddies were a motley crew of mostly African Americans, many of them addicts of one sort or another. But he found that unlike the club members, they had a lot to offer.
“They were really smart and funny, and I learned a lot from them,” he recalls. “And the people we were working for were the richest people in the Bay Area like [Bechtel Corporation scion] Stephen Bechtel Jr. and a couple of ‘Bankers,’ of Coldwell Banker, and Dick Landis, who was the CEO of Del Monte, and all these kinds of people. And they were idiots! Later, in retrospect, I realized oh my god, what a class lesson that was, to learn about that disparity of polite but really stupid people who own everything, versus the very bright and sarcastic and in some ways, very cynical, poor guys who were the caddies.”
:)
But if he wasn’t always anti-tech, Carlsson was most definitely an anti-capitalist. He’d grown up in North Oakland, and a high school gig caddying at the exclusive Claremont Country Club was a formative experience: His fellow caddies were a motley crew of mostly African Americans, many of them addicts of one sort or another. But he found that unlike the club members, they had a lot to offer.
“They were really smart and funny, and I learned a lot from them,” he recalls. “And the people we were working for were the richest people in the Bay Area like [Bechtel Corporation scion] Stephen Bechtel Jr. and a couple of ‘Bankers,’ of Coldwell Banker, and Dick Landis, who was the CEO of Del Monte, and all these kinds of people. And they were idiots! Later, in retrospect, I realized oh my god, what a class lesson that was, to learn about that disparity of polite but really stupid people who own everything, versus the very bright and sarcastic and in some ways, very cynical, poor guys who were the caddies.”
:)
On a Friday evening in early 2000, I was taking the short, steep walk down from my apartment on Telegraph Hill to our latest “rooftop” party, at Bimbo’s in North Beach. I was weary of the routine, truth be told: I’d been working seventy to eighty hours a week for almost three years, and the Friday afternoon closing of the magazine was still very stressful, in part because it had gotten so massive. When we were done, I was usually exhausted and just wanted to chill.
My presence was mandatory though, and as I crossed Washington Square, I saw a line of mostly white youngsters in jeans and shirtsleeves snaking up Columbus Avenue and around the corner. Surely this couldn’t be a line for the party, I thought; Bimbo’s was a big place, and there was no way it could be overflowing. But it was. I made my way inside and forged through the raucous, shoulder-to-shoulder crowd, eventually reaching a terrace where I could observe the scene below. The buffet table was piled high with shrimp and champagne, the open bar was flowing and I didn’t recognize a single face in the young crowd as they scarfed the delicacies. It was all being paid for by Hewlett-Packard.
It felt unnatural, in more ways than one. North Beach was composed of old, low-rise wooden buildings, intimate in scale, with cozy cafés, family-owned restaurants and shops selling Italian sausage and pastries on the ground floors, and modest apartments above. It held treasured landmarks like the City Lights bookstore, still owned and operated by Lawrence Ferlinghetti of Beat poet fame, and Tosca Cafe, where booze was allegedly served throughout Prohibition and generations of celebrities were known to enjoy back-room cocaine. The bohemians of the 1960s had long since been priced out, but this mob of young people on the make seemed strangely out of place.
This “rooftop” also struck me as unserious, from a business standpoint, an expensive event crowded with twentysomethings, some of whom were committed entrepreneurs and major talents of one sort or another, but many of whom were recent college grads who’d come to San Francisco for the party, or the chance to get rich, or simply the opportunity to be themselves—the reason so many before them had come. Nothing against any of that. But my gut said most in this crowd were tourists, here for the boom today, but gone tomorrow if and when things went south.
On a Friday evening in early 2000, I was taking the short, steep walk down from my apartment on Telegraph Hill to our latest “rooftop” party, at Bimbo’s in North Beach. I was weary of the routine, truth be told: I’d been working seventy to eighty hours a week for almost three years, and the Friday afternoon closing of the magazine was still very stressful, in part because it had gotten so massive. When we were done, I was usually exhausted and just wanted to chill.
My presence was mandatory though, and as I crossed Washington Square, I saw a line of mostly white youngsters in jeans and shirtsleeves snaking up Columbus Avenue and around the corner. Surely this couldn’t be a line for the party, I thought; Bimbo’s was a big place, and there was no way it could be overflowing. But it was. I made my way inside and forged through the raucous, shoulder-to-shoulder crowd, eventually reaching a terrace where I could observe the scene below. The buffet table was piled high with shrimp and champagne, the open bar was flowing and I didn’t recognize a single face in the young crowd as they scarfed the delicacies. It was all being paid for by Hewlett-Packard.
It felt unnatural, in more ways than one. North Beach was composed of old, low-rise wooden buildings, intimate in scale, with cozy cafés, family-owned restaurants and shops selling Italian sausage and pastries on the ground floors, and modest apartments above. It held treasured landmarks like the City Lights bookstore, still owned and operated by Lawrence Ferlinghetti of Beat poet fame, and Tosca Cafe, where booze was allegedly served throughout Prohibition and generations of celebrities were known to enjoy back-room cocaine. The bohemians of the 1960s had long since been priced out, but this mob of young people on the make seemed strangely out of place.
This “rooftop” also struck me as unserious, from a business standpoint, an expensive event crowded with twentysomethings, some of whom were committed entrepreneurs and major talents of one sort or another, but many of whom were recent college grads who’d come to San Francisco for the party, or the chance to get rich, or simply the opportunity to be themselves—the reason so many before them had come. Nothing against any of that. But my gut said most in this crowd were tourists, here for the boom today, but gone tomorrow if and when things went south.
The fourth son of the oil baron John Paul Getty, Gordon Getty was enamored with music and anthropology from a young age and never got much respect as a businessman from his father. But he was a central player in a convoluted series of events that led to the sale of Getty Oil in the mid-1980s, which yielded a family fortune that in today’s dollars would be worth more than $10 billion. Gordon had eloped with a striking redhead and Berkeley grad from the Central Valley named Ann Gilbert back in 1964, and she’d ensconced herself as the undisputed queen of San Francisco high society, a small but robust clique of families who’d made serious money building California into an economic colossus, and later in marketing its style to the world. Gordon and Ann had four boys, and Gordon settled into an exotic life as a composer and art collector (and, as it was revealed only in 1999, the paramour of a woman in Los Angeles with whom he had three daughters).
Dynastic fortunes had a lot of throw weight in San Francisco. There were the Stanfords, the Crockers, the Huntingtons and the Hopkins, all of the Southern Pacific Railroad, and then the Hearsts (mining, media and real estate), the Floods (silver), the Fishers (The Gap), the Haases (Levi’s), the Swigs (hotels) and the Bechtels (construction), to name only the most prominent. All wielded great influence at various junctures. But none in quite the style of the Gettys.
jesus
The fourth son of the oil baron John Paul Getty, Gordon Getty was enamored with music and anthropology from a young age and never got much respect as a businessman from his father. But he was a central player in a convoluted series of events that led to the sale of Getty Oil in the mid-1980s, which yielded a family fortune that in today’s dollars would be worth more than $10 billion. Gordon had eloped with a striking redhead and Berkeley grad from the Central Valley named Ann Gilbert back in 1964, and she’d ensconced herself as the undisputed queen of San Francisco high society, a small but robust clique of families who’d made serious money building California into an economic colossus, and later in marketing its style to the world. Gordon and Ann had four boys, and Gordon settled into an exotic life as a composer and art collector (and, as it was revealed only in 1999, the paramour of a woman in Los Angeles with whom he had three daughters).
Dynastic fortunes had a lot of throw weight in San Francisco. There were the Stanfords, the Crockers, the Huntingtons and the Hopkins, all of the Southern Pacific Railroad, and then the Hearsts (mining, media and real estate), the Floods (silver), the Fishers (The Gap), the Haases (Levi’s), the Swigs (hotels) and the Bechtels (construction), to name only the most prominent. All wielded great influence at various junctures. But none in quite the style of the Gettys.
jesus
The Balboa Cafe, indeed, was once a working-class dive. But the Marina, with its peerless location on the city’s northern waterfront, had been moving upscale for years, and extensive rebuilding after the 1989 quake—which destroyed or seriously damaged about seventy buildings in the neighborhood—solidified it as a prime destination for moneyed young professionals, many in finance and law. Animated young women in short summer dresses, seemingly straight out of the magazine ads for Banana Republic or Esprit, crowded the Balboa Cafe night after night, along with their boaty, Polo-wearing male counterparts, a running frat party for the established upper crust.
lol
The Balboa Cafe, indeed, was once a working-class dive. But the Marina, with its peerless location on the city’s northern waterfront, had been moving upscale for years, and extensive rebuilding after the 1989 quake—which destroyed or seriously damaged about seventy buildings in the neighborhood—solidified it as a prime destination for moneyed young professionals, many in finance and law. Animated young women in short summer dresses, seemingly straight out of the magazine ads for Banana Republic or Esprit, crowded the Balboa Cafe night after night, along with their boaty, Polo-wearing male counterparts, a running frat party for the established upper crust.
lol
Whatever the programs’ merits, though, there is one thing they definitely did not do: solve the city’s homelessness problem. There was no major effort to spur housing construction under Newsom, and drug-treatment and mental health services were still wanting. Angela Alioto says her ten-year plan for homelessness, which included a lot more supportive and subsidized housing, would have worked were it not for the new tech boom that began driving up prices and squeezing affordability at the end of the decade.
In truth, nobody had achievable solutions. Poverty, mental illness and drug addiction were at the root of homelessness, and the scope of those problems was daunting and stretched far beyond the city.
technically not wrong tho i dont like the equal weight given to poverty, mental illness and drug addiction ... rich people deal with the latter two all the time but they dont have to become homeless ... it's a matter of societal design
Whatever the programs’ merits, though, there is one thing they definitely did not do: solve the city’s homelessness problem. There was no major effort to spur housing construction under Newsom, and drug-treatment and mental health services were still wanting. Angela Alioto says her ten-year plan for homelessness, which included a lot more supportive and subsidized housing, would have worked were it not for the new tech boom that began driving up prices and squeezing affordability at the end of the decade.
In truth, nobody had achievable solutions. Poverty, mental illness and drug addiction were at the root of homelessness, and the scope of those problems was daunting and stretched far beyond the city.
technically not wrong tho i dont like the equal weight given to poverty, mental illness and drug addiction ... rich people deal with the latter two all the time but they dont have to become homeless ... it's a matter of societal design
Craig Newmark, meanwhile, was solidifying his place in the rarefied club of entrepreneurs for whom fast growth and big profits were not a priority. He was again ignoring the waves of venture capital dollars that had started to sweep across San Francisco. He’d promoted a programmer from Michigan named Jim Buckmaster to CEO of Craigslist, and they resisted constant entreaties to sell, even fighting a nasty legal battle with eBay after the auction site, which pined for the classifieds business, acquired shares of the privately owned Craigslist from a former employee. The two of them—Buckmaster very tall and thin, Newmark short and round—gave a memorable comic performance at an early Web 2.0 conference, riffing off each other as they mocked the pieties of the startup world and voiced their commitment to “unbranding” and “demonetization.”
Newmark was a brilliant representative of the city’s early Internet spirit, and the idea that the Web was a medium for the people. At the same moment, though, Web 2.0 was seeding a generation of San Francisco companies that would raise more money than any startup ventures had ever done before. Their extraordinary growth would bring both prosperity and political strife to the city—and ultimately challenge the idea that the rise of the Internet was good for San Francisco, and for humanity.
<333
Craig Newmark, meanwhile, was solidifying his place in the rarefied club of entrepreneurs for whom fast growth and big profits were not a priority. He was again ignoring the waves of venture capital dollars that had started to sweep across San Francisco. He’d promoted a programmer from Michigan named Jim Buckmaster to CEO of Craigslist, and they resisted constant entreaties to sell, even fighting a nasty legal battle with eBay after the auction site, which pined for the classifieds business, acquired shares of the privately owned Craigslist from a former employee. The two of them—Buckmaster very tall and thin, Newmark short and round—gave a memorable comic performance at an early Web 2.0 conference, riffing off each other as they mocked the pieties of the startup world and voiced their commitment to “unbranding” and “demonetization.”
Newmark was a brilliant representative of the city’s early Internet spirit, and the idea that the Web was a medium for the people. At the same moment, though, Web 2.0 was seeding a generation of San Francisco companies that would raise more money than any startup ventures had ever done before. Their extraordinary growth would bring both prosperity and political strife to the city—and ultimately challenge the idea that the rise of the Internet was good for San Francisco, and for humanity.
<333
There was another issue on the table, though, one that neither the company nor its prospective landlord could resolve on its own: The city at the time had a payroll tax, which cost all but the smallest companies 1.5 percent of their wage bill. Twitter was moving toward a public stock offering that would rain money on many top execs and employees, and the payroll tax, which no other city in Northern California imposed, would put the company on the hook for tens of millions of dollars in taxes for the IPO gains alone.
If it was going to move into 1355 Market, Twitter wanted tax relief. Otherwise, company executives said, they would have to leave town. The cities of South San Francisco and Brisbane were only a few minutes away on the 101 freeway.
It would be a very bad look for the city to lose one of the hottest companies of the moment, especially one whose philosophy and purpose seemed to fit San Francisco so well. Even more urgently, the Great Recession had again spotlighted the city’s vulnerabilities. “It was a really scary time in terms of the economy, it felt bottomless,” recounted Jason Elliott, a top aide to Newsom at the time. “The only thing anyone cared about was jobs, jobs, jobs. When you’re at double-digit unemployment, you can’t be sitting there talking about mandatory composting programs or plastic bag bans. People need jobs.”
ugh. whatever. let them move. people will still ilve in san francisco
There was another issue on the table, though, one that neither the company nor its prospective landlord could resolve on its own: The city at the time had a payroll tax, which cost all but the smallest companies 1.5 percent of their wage bill. Twitter was moving toward a public stock offering that would rain money on many top execs and employees, and the payroll tax, which no other city in Northern California imposed, would put the company on the hook for tens of millions of dollars in taxes for the IPO gains alone.
If it was going to move into 1355 Market, Twitter wanted tax relief. Otherwise, company executives said, they would have to leave town. The cities of South San Francisco and Brisbane were only a few minutes away on the 101 freeway.
It would be a very bad look for the city to lose one of the hottest companies of the moment, especially one whose philosophy and purpose seemed to fit San Francisco so well. Even more urgently, the Great Recession had again spotlighted the city’s vulnerabilities. “It was a really scary time in terms of the economy, it felt bottomless,” recounted Jason Elliott, a top aide to Newsom at the time. “The only thing anyone cared about was jobs, jobs, jobs. When you’re at double-digit unemployment, you can’t be sitting there talking about mandatory composting programs or plastic bag bans. People need jobs.”
ugh. whatever. let them move. people will still ilve in san francisco