There was another issue on the table, though, one that neither the company nor its prospective landlord could resolve on its own: The city at the time had a payroll tax, which cost all but the smallest companies 1.5 percent of their wage bill. Twitter was moving toward a public stock offering that would rain money on many top execs and employees, and the payroll tax, which no other city in Northern California imposed, would put the company on the hook for tens of millions of dollars in taxes for the IPO gains alone.
If it was going to move into 1355 Market, Twitter wanted tax relief. Otherwise, company executives said, they would have to leave town. The cities of South San Francisco and Brisbane were only a few minutes away on the 101 freeway.
It would be a very bad look for the city to lose one of the hottest companies of the moment, especially one whose philosophy and purpose seemed to fit San Francisco so well. Even more urgently, the Great Recession had again spotlighted the city’s vulnerabilities. “It was a really scary time in terms of the economy, it felt bottomless,” recounted Jason Elliott, a top aide to Newsom at the time. “The only thing anyone cared about was jobs, jobs, jobs. When you’re at double-digit unemployment, you can’t be sitting there talking about mandatory composting programs or plastic bag bans. People need jobs.”
ugh. whatever. let them move. people will still ilve in san francisco
There was another issue on the table, though, one that neither the company nor its prospective landlord could resolve on its own: The city at the time had a payroll tax, which cost all but the smallest companies 1.5 percent of their wage bill. Twitter was moving toward a public stock offering that would rain money on many top execs and employees, and the payroll tax, which no other city in Northern California imposed, would put the company on the hook for tens of millions of dollars in taxes for the IPO gains alone.
If it was going to move into 1355 Market, Twitter wanted tax relief. Otherwise, company executives said, they would have to leave town. The cities of South San Francisco and Brisbane were only a few minutes away on the 101 freeway.
It would be a very bad look for the city to lose one of the hottest companies of the moment, especially one whose philosophy and purpose seemed to fit San Francisco so well. Even more urgently, the Great Recession had again spotlighted the city’s vulnerabilities. “It was a really scary time in terms of the economy, it felt bottomless,” recounted Jason Elliott, a top aide to Newsom at the time. “The only thing anyone cared about was jobs, jobs, jobs. When you’re at double-digit unemployment, you can’t be sitting there talking about mandatory composting programs or plastic bag bans. People need jobs.”
ugh. whatever. let them move. people will still ilve in san francisco
Mark Pincus’s game company, Zynga, was blowing up, and it was on a path to an IPO too. It had just moved into its new home in the SoMa neighborhood known as Showplace Square, but it was outside the tax-break district, and Zynga leadership hadn’t been aware of how the city’s payroll tax would hit an IPO. Costolo says it was Twitter’s finance team that alerted Zynga to the issue, and though Pincus doesn’t recall that detail, he does remember his indignation in learning about it. Between the IPO and the regular payroll tax levy, Zynga looked to be on the hook for $80 million in city taxes, he says, and the company’s CFO was soon raising the relocation issue with the Board. “He’s like, ‘Here are some headquarters options, because we’re definitely not going to pay the $80 million,’ ” Pincus said later. He thought the payroll tax was outrageous. And like many tech CEOs, he was offended by the attitude behind it. “There’s a cultural thing that’s getting lost here,” Pincus said. “Politicians should want you here.” Certainly Pincus’s own vision for San Francisco was a business-friendly one, with entrepreneurship and economic growth at the heart of it.
Pincus then did what you have to do when you have a problem with San Francisco’s government: He hired a lobbyist. It turned out a lot of people in the business community were unhappy that the Twitter tax break offered relief only for companies in a specific part of town. Soon the Board of Supervisors was considering another piece of legislation that would eliminate the payroll tax on IPO proceeds for all companies. Pincus’s lobbyist, Chris Gruwell, told him the swing vote on the Board was the idiosyncratic Green Party supervisor Ross Mirkarimi, and the way to get to him was through the hotel workers’ union. So Pincus took some meetings, including one with the service employees’ union boss, a famously tough character named Olga Miranda.
Mirkarimi came around, and just a couple of months after approving the Twitter tax break, and with far less fanfare, the Board of Supervisors passed the IPO tax-relief bill. The Twitter tax break was attacked for years as a giveaway to the tech industry, but this second step would be a much bigger hit to city tax revenues.
lol
Mark Pincus’s game company, Zynga, was blowing up, and it was on a path to an IPO too. It had just moved into its new home in the SoMa neighborhood known as Showplace Square, but it was outside the tax-break district, and Zynga leadership hadn’t been aware of how the city’s payroll tax would hit an IPO. Costolo says it was Twitter’s finance team that alerted Zynga to the issue, and though Pincus doesn’t recall that detail, he does remember his indignation in learning about it. Between the IPO and the regular payroll tax levy, Zynga looked to be on the hook for $80 million in city taxes, he says, and the company’s CFO was soon raising the relocation issue with the Board. “He’s like, ‘Here are some headquarters options, because we’re definitely not going to pay the $80 million,’ ” Pincus said later. He thought the payroll tax was outrageous. And like many tech CEOs, he was offended by the attitude behind it. “There’s a cultural thing that’s getting lost here,” Pincus said. “Politicians should want you here.” Certainly Pincus’s own vision for San Francisco was a business-friendly one, with entrepreneurship and economic growth at the heart of it.
Pincus then did what you have to do when you have a problem with San Francisco’s government: He hired a lobbyist. It turned out a lot of people in the business community were unhappy that the Twitter tax break offered relief only for companies in a specific part of town. Soon the Board of Supervisors was considering another piece of legislation that would eliminate the payroll tax on IPO proceeds for all companies. Pincus’s lobbyist, Chris Gruwell, told him the swing vote on the Board was the idiosyncratic Green Party supervisor Ross Mirkarimi, and the way to get to him was through the hotel workers’ union. So Pincus took some meetings, including one with the service employees’ union boss, a famously tough character named Olga Miranda.
Mirkarimi came around, and just a couple of months after approving the Twitter tax break, and with far less fanfare, the Board of Supervisors passed the IPO tax-relief bill. The Twitter tax break was attacked for years as a giveaway to the tech industry, but this second step would be a much bigger hit to city tax revenues.
lol