Bookmarker is a personal project by @dellsystem to help with retaining reading material. Source on GitHub.
157

Left sectarianism was not the only basis for expulsions. In 1948 the party’s State Review Commission drafted a report on its work over the three years since the reorganization. Noting that its most important work had been “smashing” the left sectarian faction, the committee’s draft also reported on other investigations and expulsions: “In the course of the past three years, we conducted 300 hearings, expelling 70 members for ‘left-sectarianism’, and 10 ‘Right Opportunists’[sic] 2 stoolpigeons, 5 homo-sexuals“ [cross-out in draft, with “morally corrupt” written in with pencil].” The draft report noted that the California party had expelled some four hundred individuals over the previous fifteen years, the largest number of whom were “swindlers, thieves and financially irresponsible people,” followed by “Trotskyites and other ‘political’ revisers of Marxism” along with “paid informers and stool-pigeons.” The draft added, “In every one of the groupings, we find that the majority were guilty of [white] chauvinism or anti-semitism,” and concluded that this experience emphasized the continuing “necessity for struggle” against “rotten liberalism” (tolerance inside the party of those who disagreed with the official party line) and “such fascist ideas as chauvinism and anti-semitism.” The report singled out Harrison George: “Can Harrison George deny seeking to obtain documents from Union offices by theft? . . . Can Harrison George deny that he connived and planned to seize the People’s World through members of the Board of Directors?”

—p.157 The Party in Crisis, 1945–1950 (145) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago

Left sectarianism was not the only basis for expulsions. In 1948 the party’s State Review Commission drafted a report on its work over the three years since the reorganization. Noting that its most important work had been “smashing” the left sectarian faction, the committee’s draft also reported on other investigations and expulsions: “In the course of the past three years, we conducted 300 hearings, expelling 70 members for ‘left-sectarianism’, and 10 ‘Right Opportunists’[sic] 2 stoolpigeons, 5 homo-sexuals“ [cross-out in draft, with “morally corrupt” written in with pencil].” The draft report noted that the California party had expelled some four hundred individuals over the previous fifteen years, the largest number of whom were “swindlers, thieves and financially irresponsible people,” followed by “Trotskyites and other ‘political’ revisers of Marxism” along with “paid informers and stool-pigeons.” The draft added, “In every one of the groupings, we find that the majority were guilty of [white] chauvinism or anti-semitism,” and concluded that this experience emphasized the continuing “necessity for struggle” against “rotten liberalism” (tolerance inside the party of those who disagreed with the official party line) and “such fascist ideas as chauvinism and anti-semitism.” The report singled out Harrison George: “Can Harrison George deny seeking to obtain documents from Union offices by theft? . . . Can Harrison George deny that he connived and planned to seize the People’s World through members of the Board of Directors?”

—p.157 The Party in Crisis, 1945–1950 (145) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago
158

With the party under attack on all sides, and given harsh penalties under state law for homosexual behavior and smoking marijuana, the party feared that anyone charged under such laws might turn informer. One draft report noted, “Due to laws recently enacted in California re. homosexuals . . . (20 years in prison on act or failure to report and register as homo if practicing) . . . they have become greatest liability in and around the Party.” All known lesbian and gay party members were expelled or dropped. One internal draft report noted, “Certainly there are comrades who, and justifiably so, feel sorry for these comrades when they are asked to leave our movement, but we must always keep in mind the methods the bourgeoise [sic] uses to exploit these people.”40

—p.158 The Party in Crisis, 1945–1950 (145) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago

With the party under attack on all sides, and given harsh penalties under state law for homosexual behavior and smoking marijuana, the party feared that anyone charged under such laws might turn informer. One draft report noted, “Due to laws recently enacted in California re. homosexuals . . . (20 years in prison on act or failure to report and register as homo if practicing) . . . they have become greatest liability in and around the Party.” All known lesbian and gay party members were expelled or dropped. One internal draft report noted, “Certainly there are comrades who, and justifiably so, feel sorry for these comrades when they are asked to leave our movement, but we must always keep in mind the methods the bourgeoise [sic] uses to exploit these people.”40

—p.158 The Party in Crisis, 1945–1950 (145) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago
159

In the late 1940s, coincident with a Soviet campaign against national chauvinism in Eastern Europe, the U.S. party launched a campaign against white chauvinism, which it described as the key underlying feature of American capitalism’s success in keeping the working class divided.45 The campaign quickly degenerated. Dorothy Ray Healey, then a CP leader in Los Angeles, reflected, “A legitimate concern turned into an obsession” and became “a ritual act of self-purification that did nothing to strengthen the Party in its fight against racism and was manipulated by some Communist leaders for ends which had nothing to do with the ostensible purpose of the whole campaign.” She added, “Once an accusation of white chauvinism was thrown against a white Communist, there was no defense.” In Los Angeles, Healey estimated, the party expelled or dropped two hundred people, “usually on the most trivial of pretexts.” Healey’s description was as accurate for San Francisco as for Los Angeles. CP members who ran afoul of prominent party members were called before the Security Commission, charged with white chauvinism, and expelled or dropped.

—p.159 The Party in Crisis, 1945–1950 (145) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago

In the late 1940s, coincident with a Soviet campaign against national chauvinism in Eastern Europe, the U.S. party launched a campaign against white chauvinism, which it described as the key underlying feature of American capitalism’s success in keeping the working class divided.45 The campaign quickly degenerated. Dorothy Ray Healey, then a CP leader in Los Angeles, reflected, “A legitimate concern turned into an obsession” and became “a ritual act of self-purification that did nothing to strengthen the Party in its fight against racism and was manipulated by some Communist leaders for ends which had nothing to do with the ostensible purpose of the whole campaign.” She added, “Once an accusation of white chauvinism was thrown against a white Communist, there was no defense.” In Los Angeles, Healey estimated, the party expelled or dropped two hundred people, “usually on the most trivial of pretexts.” Healey’s description was as accurate for San Francisco as for Los Angeles. CP members who ran afoul of prominent party members were called before the Security Commission, charged with white chauvinism, and expelled or dropped.

—p.159 The Party in Crisis, 1945–1950 (145) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago
160

After his discharge from the army, Keith Eickman returned to Local 6, moved from the YCL to the CP, and attended CLS classes. He was expelled or dropped from the CP in 1953, during the white chauvinism campaign, which he later called “a hysteria within the CP.” The charge against him was that in a meeting of union stewards he had disagreed with a Black steward who, Eickman later said, was and remained a close friend. Regarding the white chauvinism campaign, Eickman later said, it “was useful . . . to some people who wanted to get rid of some of the others.” He added, “They probably did me a favor. . . . It would have been difficult for me to voluntarily separate myself from the CP.”

Dorothy Ray Healey added, “One of the great ironies of the white chauvinism campaign is that we lost a large number of Black members. . . . They were just contemptuous of the whole thing because it had so little to do with fighting racism in the real world.”

—p.160 The Party in Crisis, 1945–1950 (145) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago

After his discharge from the army, Keith Eickman returned to Local 6, moved from the YCL to the CP, and attended CLS classes. He was expelled or dropped from the CP in 1953, during the white chauvinism campaign, which he later called “a hysteria within the CP.” The charge against him was that in a meeting of union stewards he had disagreed with a Black steward who, Eickman later said, was and remained a close friend. Regarding the white chauvinism campaign, Eickman later said, it “was useful . . . to some people who wanted to get rid of some of the others.” He added, “They probably did me a favor. . . . It would have been difficult for me to voluntarily separate myself from the CP.”

Dorothy Ray Healey added, “One of the great ironies of the white chauvinism campaign is that we lost a large number of Black members. . . . They were just contemptuous of the whole thing because it had so little to do with fighting racism in the real world.”

—p.160 The Party in Crisis, 1945–1950 (145) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago
200

Bill Sennett’s post-party employment was perhaps most at variance from his erstwhile comrades. Within six years he had become a corporate vice president for the company where he had worked in Chicago, and he eventually became president of an international corporation that leased truck trailers for heavy freight. In addition to his corporate positions, he belonged to the Democratic Socialists of America and helped organize a tenants’ association at the high-rise luxury apartment complex where he lived. In retirement in Tiburon, an affluent suburb north of San Francisco, he became publisher of In These Times, a weekly that presented left perspectives on current events and supported organizations that worked to eliminate poverty and racial discrimination.

ha nice

—p.200 The Crisis of 1956–1958, the Collapse of the Old Left, and After (181) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago

Bill Sennett’s post-party employment was perhaps most at variance from his erstwhile comrades. Within six years he had become a corporate vice president for the company where he had worked in Chicago, and he eventually became president of an international corporation that leased truck trailers for heavy freight. In addition to his corporate positions, he belonged to the Democratic Socialists of America and helped organize a tenants’ association at the high-rise luxury apartment complex where he lived. In retirement in Tiburon, an affluent suburb north of San Francisco, he became publisher of In These Times, a weekly that presented left perspectives on current events and supported organizations that worked to eliminate poverty and racial discrimination.

ha nice

—p.200 The Crisis of 1956–1958, the Collapse of the Old Left, and After (181) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago
203

Though those who left the party could be quite critical of the party, other party members, and even themselves, few regretted the time they had given to the party. Sennett said, “My life was enriched by having been a Communist.” Eva Lapin Maas reflected, “The Party had shaped our lives, given us a way of viewing the world, framed our family life, and influenced our selection of friends, books, movies, and activities.” Bailey concluded his memoir by reiterating what had guided his life in the party: “To witness an injustice and do nothing—that is the biggest crime.” Eickman was quite critical of the CP but did not regret his time as a member. “The Party gave me an understanding of the class relationship of society,” he said. “It gave me a political attitude that made me different from any of the others in the union who didn’t have that background. I don’t think they understood politics to the same degree.” Tobin also voiced no regrets: “I don’t think anything I ever did countered the interests of the people in this country. . . . What we went out to do, was a good cause.” Angela Gizzi Ward considered that her experience in the party had been “positive,” that she had “learned a great deal,” and that whatever success she had as a union organizer came in part “because of the support I did get from the Party in thinking, and in organizing my ideas.” Carol Cuénod’s major regret was that the Labor Youth League she led had advised high school students to work in factories rather than go to college.

—p.203 The Crisis of 1956–1958, the Collapse of the Old Left, and After (181) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago

Though those who left the party could be quite critical of the party, other party members, and even themselves, few regretted the time they had given to the party. Sennett said, “My life was enriched by having been a Communist.” Eva Lapin Maas reflected, “The Party had shaped our lives, given us a way of viewing the world, framed our family life, and influenced our selection of friends, books, movies, and activities.” Bailey concluded his memoir by reiterating what had guided his life in the party: “To witness an injustice and do nothing—that is the biggest crime.” Eickman was quite critical of the CP but did not regret his time as a member. “The Party gave me an understanding of the class relationship of society,” he said. “It gave me a political attitude that made me different from any of the others in the union who didn’t have that background. I don’t think they understood politics to the same degree.” Tobin also voiced no regrets: “I don’t think anything I ever did countered the interests of the people in this country. . . . What we went out to do, was a good cause.” Angela Gizzi Ward considered that her experience in the party had been “positive,” that she had “learned a great deal,” and that whatever success she had as a union organizer came in part “because of the support I did get from the Party in thinking, and in organizing my ideas.” Carol Cuénod’s major regret was that the Labor Youth League she led had advised high school students to work in factories rather than go to college.

—p.203 The Crisis of 1956–1958, the Collapse of the Old Left, and After (181) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago
206

In 1983, on the fiftieth anniversary of the time Elaine and Karl moved in together, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors presented them with a certificate of honor that noted their lifetimes of effort for “Labor, Civil Rights, Peace, and Against Racism” and stated that “their example has been an inspiration to many of us.” The San Francisco Examiner devoted an article to their lifelong commitment to the CP, noting that “their lives are almost synonymous with labor organizing, civil and racial rights causes and an unceasing commitment to involvement.” When Elaine died five years later, Walter Johnson, secretary of the San Francisco Labor Council, spoke at her memorial service and observed that for many years no picket line in the city had been complete without the presence of Elaine and Karl.

<3

—p.206 The Crisis of 1956–1958, the Collapse of the Old Left, and After (181) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago

In 1983, on the fiftieth anniversary of the time Elaine and Karl moved in together, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors presented them with a certificate of honor that noted their lifetimes of effort for “Labor, Civil Rights, Peace, and Against Racism” and stated that “their example has been an inspiration to many of us.” The San Francisco Examiner devoted an article to their lifelong commitment to the CP, noting that “their lives are almost synonymous with labor organizing, civil and racial rights causes and an unceasing commitment to involvement.” When Elaine died five years later, Walter Johnson, secretary of the San Francisco Labor Council, spoke at her memorial service and observed that for many years no picket line in the city had been complete without the presence of Elaine and Karl.

<3

—p.206 The Crisis of 1956–1958, the Collapse of the Old Left, and After (181) by Robert W. Cherny 4 months ago