The party soon completed its transition from persistent and vitriolic critic of Roosevelt and the New Deal to staunch supporter. On January 1, 1938, District 13 launched a new newspaper, People’s World (PW), a daily paper replacing the semiweekly WW. Al Richmond, the new managing editor, twenty-three years old, brought three years of experience at the Daily Worker. Harrison George became executive editor, his duties limited to writing editorials and a personal column. Like the party, the new paper moved toward the mainstream, featuring some news stories with little or no political commentary. The final page became a sports page, and columns dealt with movies, radio programs, art, and helpful hints for women. Typical of most daily papers at the time, photos of attractive young women in skimpy outfits appeared regularly. Saturday’s paper included a magazine with articles by prominent liberals as well as CP members, a woman’s page (including Comrade Kitty’s tips on how to be fashionable on a budget), a page for children, and a page of comics—though the comics were definitely political. Glowing accounts about the Soviet Union and Stalin’s speeches still appeared but were fewer in number. Articles by non-Communist liberals began to appear, including Upton Sinclair, no longer a fascist or social fascist. George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Andrew Jackson, and, especially, Abraham Lincoln all received positive stories. Along with the new format came a full-blown embrace of FDR and the New Deal. On January 5, 1938, an editorial announced, “Mr. President, We’re Behind You!”
damn that's crazy
The party soon completed its transition from persistent and vitriolic critic of Roosevelt and the New Deal to staunch supporter. On January 1, 1938, District 13 launched a new newspaper, People’s World (PW), a daily paper replacing the semiweekly WW. Al Richmond, the new managing editor, twenty-three years old, brought three years of experience at the Daily Worker. Harrison George became executive editor, his duties limited to writing editorials and a personal column. Like the party, the new paper moved toward the mainstream, featuring some news stories with little or no political commentary. The final page became a sports page, and columns dealt with movies, radio programs, art, and helpful hints for women. Typical of most daily papers at the time, photos of attractive young women in skimpy outfits appeared regularly. Saturday’s paper included a magazine with articles by prominent liberals as well as CP members, a woman’s page (including Comrade Kitty’s tips on how to be fashionable on a budget), a page for children, and a page of comics—though the comics were definitely political. Glowing accounts about the Soviet Union and Stalin’s speeches still appeared but were fewer in number. Articles by non-Communist liberals began to appear, including Upton Sinclair, no longer a fascist or social fascist. George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Andrew Jackson, and, especially, Abraham Lincoln all received positive stories. Along with the new format came a full-blown embrace of FDR and the New Deal. On January 5, 1938, an editorial announced, “Mr. President, We’re Behind You!”
damn that's crazy
In the 1938 general election, a coalition of business and conservative groups tried to constrain the state’s robust union movement through a ballot initiative. Proposition 1 originated with the Industrial Association of San Francisco (which a U.S. Senate investigating committee chaired by Robert La Follette Jr. had recently called “an example par excellence of . . . success in denying labor its collective-bargaining rights”), the Associated Farmers (which Carey McWilliams labeled “farm fascism” and which the La Follette Committee accused of “flagrant and violent infringement of civil liberties”), the Merchants and Manufacturers Association of Los Angeles (the state’s oldest, and highly successful, advocate of the open shop; the La Follette Committee claimed it “arrogated to itself the determination of what constituted law and order”), the Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce, and Southern Californians Inc. (an arch-conservative group dedicated to “preservation of industrial freedom”).
Proposition 1 proposed to restrict picketing, prohibit secondary boycotts, make unions liable for damages caused by members, and more. Its supporters launched the state’s most expensive campaign for a proposition up to that time. Those efforts were closely tied to leading Republican candidates, Frank Merriam, the incumbent governor who was seeking a third term, and Philip Bancroft, candidate for U.S. Senate, who had connections to the Associated Farmers.
near the end
In the 1938 general election, a coalition of business and conservative groups tried to constrain the state’s robust union movement through a ballot initiative. Proposition 1 originated with the Industrial Association of San Francisco (which a U.S. Senate investigating committee chaired by Robert La Follette Jr. had recently called “an example par excellence of . . . success in denying labor its collective-bargaining rights”), the Associated Farmers (which Carey McWilliams labeled “farm fascism” and which the La Follette Committee accused of “flagrant and violent infringement of civil liberties”), the Merchants and Manufacturers Association of Los Angeles (the state’s oldest, and highly successful, advocate of the open shop; the La Follette Committee claimed it “arrogated to itself the determination of what constituted law and order”), the Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce, and Southern Californians Inc. (an arch-conservative group dedicated to “preservation of industrial freedom”).
Proposition 1 proposed to restrict picketing, prohibit secondary boycotts, make unions liable for damages caused by members, and more. Its supporters launched the state’s most expensive campaign for a proposition up to that time. Those efforts were closely tied to leading Republican candidates, Frank Merriam, the incumbent governor who was seeking a third term, and Philip Bancroft, candidate for U.S. Senate, who had connections to the Associated Farmers.
near the end
The 1934 strikes were important catalysts for many. Edith Arnstein’s family came to San Francisco during the Gold Rush and were related to several of the city’s elite German Jewish families. She later described the summer of 1934: “A long and bloody strike has divided the city. In middle-class homes the family is sharply divided, so that dinner tables are barricades—mothers and children on the side of the strikers, businessmen fathers on the side of the employers.” She recalled that she and a friend borrowed twenty-five dollars (equivalent to more than five hundred dollars in 2023) from her mother to contribute to the MWIU, and how, on the day of a dramatic funeral march down Market Street, she and her cousin watched from the sidewalk: “She says, ‘I am going to march.’ I join her. I hope our fathers are not watching. . . . We pledge our lives that Sperry and Bordoise have not laid down their lives in vain.” Angela Gizzi, daughter of middle-class Italian immigrants, left work to stand in respect during the funeral procession down Market Street; she called it “the most spectacular thing I’ve ever seen,” and said it made her “a radical.”
The 1934 strikes were important catalysts for many. Edith Arnstein’s family came to San Francisco during the Gold Rush and were related to several of the city’s elite German Jewish families. She later described the summer of 1934: “A long and bloody strike has divided the city. In middle-class homes the family is sharply divided, so that dinner tables are barricades—mothers and children on the side of the strikers, businessmen fathers on the side of the employers.” She recalled that she and a friend borrowed twenty-five dollars (equivalent to more than five hundred dollars in 2023) from her mother to contribute to the MWIU, and how, on the day of a dramatic funeral march down Market Street, she and her cousin watched from the sidewalk: “She says, ‘I am going to march.’ I join her. I hope our fathers are not watching. . . . We pledge our lives that Sperry and Bordoise have not laid down their lives in vain.” Angela Gizzi, daughter of middle-class Italian immigrants, left work to stand in respect during the funeral procession down Market Street; she called it “the most spectacular thing I’ve ever seen,” and said it made her “a radical.”
In the early 1930s, party members formed “fractions” within union locals, which typically met before union meetings and formulated a position that CP members were to follow when the meeting started. However, as Dorothy Ray Healey later recalled, “Some of our closest allies were unhappy about it,” and as CP members became more integrated into unions as members and leaders, the party abandoned its fraction meetings. Jack Olsen recalled, of the mid- and late 1930s, “The CP set up Party clubs on an industry-by-industry basis. There were warehousemen’s, seamen’s, and longshoremen’s clubs. Each club had its own officer and its own delegates to the CP county committee, a literature agent, and an education director. . . . We used to meet and first take up political issues like the anti-fascist cause in the Spanish Civil War, the current election campaign, or an ongoing legal defense case.”
lol
In the early 1930s, party members formed “fractions” within union locals, which typically met before union meetings and formulated a position that CP members were to follow when the meeting started. However, as Dorothy Ray Healey later recalled, “Some of our closest allies were unhappy about it,” and as CP members became more integrated into unions as members and leaders, the party abandoned its fraction meetings. Jack Olsen recalled, of the mid- and late 1930s, “The CP set up Party clubs on an industry-by-industry basis. There were warehousemen’s, seamen’s, and longshoremen’s clubs. Each club had its own officer and its own delegates to the CP county committee, a literature agent, and an education director. . . . We used to meet and first take up political issues like the anti-fascist cause in the Spanish Civil War, the current election campaign, or an ongoing legal defense case.”
lol
For Brown and Yoneda, party membership led them into union activity. Angela Gizzi’s experience provides a different pattern. Her interest in the left led her to union activism and then to the CP. She was born in San Francisco’s North Beach, an Italian neighborhood. Her parents were middle-class Italian immigrants and nominal Catholics. She graduated from the University of California, Berkeley, (UC—Berkeley) in 1931, amid the Depression, but couldn’t find a job. In 1933 she was hired by the Bank of America because of her fluent Italian and ability with Spanish and French. She’d begun to move left politically at Berkeley and after witnessing the funeral march on Market Street. In early 1936 she attended a meeting of an AFL organizing committee for white-collar workers. After speaking up in the meeting, she was invited to a party recruiting session, led by Arthur Kent. She joined. Kent, however, was an informer. He gave employers the names of those who joined the union, and they were fired. Gizzi soon met Caroline Decker, who had recently been released from prison, and they became close friends. In 1937 Gizzi was elected president of a CIO organizing committee for office workers, and she continued to work as a CIO union organizer.
Estolv Ward’s efforts to found a union led him to the CP, which led him to positions with CIO unions and central bodies. He was born in Los Angeles in 1899. His father was a lawyer and former Populist who became a Socialist, and his mother was a physician, Quaker, and feminist. They moved to the Bay Area shortly after Estolv’s birth. After attending the University of California, Ward became a reporter and eventually assistant editor for the Oakland Tribune. Covering the San Francisco general strike in 1934 led him to join the Newspaper Guild, for which he was fired. He joined the CP in 1936 and held staff positions with CIO central bodies, labor publications, and Labor’s Non-Partisan League. He was executive secretary of the Harry Bridges Defense Committee in 1939. He and Angela Gizzi were married in 1939.
love that for them
For Brown and Yoneda, party membership led them into union activity. Angela Gizzi’s experience provides a different pattern. Her interest in the left led her to union activism and then to the CP. She was born in San Francisco’s North Beach, an Italian neighborhood. Her parents were middle-class Italian immigrants and nominal Catholics. She graduated from the University of California, Berkeley, (UC—Berkeley) in 1931, amid the Depression, but couldn’t find a job. In 1933 she was hired by the Bank of America because of her fluent Italian and ability with Spanish and French. She’d begun to move left politically at Berkeley and after witnessing the funeral march on Market Street. In early 1936 she attended a meeting of an AFL organizing committee for white-collar workers. After speaking up in the meeting, she was invited to a party recruiting session, led by Arthur Kent. She joined. Kent, however, was an informer. He gave employers the names of those who joined the union, and they were fired. Gizzi soon met Caroline Decker, who had recently been released from prison, and they became close friends. In 1937 Gizzi was elected president of a CIO organizing committee for office workers, and she continued to work as a CIO union organizer.
Estolv Ward’s efforts to found a union led him to the CP, which led him to positions with CIO unions and central bodies. He was born in Los Angeles in 1899. His father was a lawyer and former Populist who became a Socialist, and his mother was a physician, Quaker, and feminist. They moved to the Bay Area shortly after Estolv’s birth. After attending the University of California, Ward became a reporter and eventually assistant editor for the Oakland Tribune. Covering the San Francisco general strike in 1934 led him to join the Newspaper Guild, for which he was fired. He joined the CP in 1936 and held staff positions with CIO central bodies, labor publications, and Labor’s Non-Partisan League. He was executive secretary of the Harry Bridges Defense Committee in 1939. He and Angela Gizzi were married in 1939.
love that for them
Arnstein graduated in 1935 and then continued for another three semesters, including some time in the law school. In 1936, while in law school, she became section organizer for the party’s professional section. She later recalled “everything was so secretive” that she didn’t even know who was in the professional section. Membership lists were kept secret, and everyone used a code name. The code name she chose was Mary Wollstonecraft, the eighteenth-century advocate for women’s rights. Having a membership card was “too dangerous,” so no one had one. She remembered the professional section as composed of several units of about eight people each; each unit met every week or two at a member’s house. Concluding that she should be a member of the working class, she quit law school, went to a business school, gave up learning to type, and got a job as a cashier at a department store in San Francisco.
ha love this
Arnstein graduated in 1935 and then continued for another three semesters, including some time in the law school. In 1936, while in law school, she became section organizer for the party’s professional section. She later recalled “everything was so secretive” that she didn’t even know who was in the professional section. Membership lists were kept secret, and everyone used a code name. The code name she chose was Mary Wollstonecraft, the eighteenth-century advocate for women’s rights. Having a membership card was “too dangerous,” so no one had one. She remembered the professional section as composed of several units of about eight people each; each unit met every week or two at a member’s house. Concluding that she should be a member of the working class, she quit law school, went to a business school, gave up learning to type, and got a job as a cashier at a department store in San Francisco.
ha love this
Observers then and later have disagreed regarding the degree to which the CP succeeded in its ambition to be a tightly disciplined organization. Even membership could be ambiguous. Caroline Decker recalled, “I never carried a book, I never paid dues. . . . As far as I was concerned, I was a member; I was prepared to give my life and I gave an awful lot of it. But . . . no evaluation papers or applications, and not even membership books. Not even dues. Where was I going to get money to pay dues?” Dorothy Ray Healey similarly recalled, “I never regularly paid dues until 1946. When you moved around a great deal, the way I did, the bookkeeping never kept up with you.” But, like Decker, she specified that “you could still be a Communist accepted by others as a Communist, whether you paid dues or not.” She added, “There is this myth that the Party ran like some kind of well-oiled machine, but it was never that well organized internally. . . . The FBI did a much better job of keeping track of our members than we did, unfortunately.”
lol
Observers then and later have disagreed regarding the degree to which the CP succeeded in its ambition to be a tightly disciplined organization. Even membership could be ambiguous. Caroline Decker recalled, “I never carried a book, I never paid dues. . . . As far as I was concerned, I was a member; I was prepared to give my life and I gave an awful lot of it. But . . . no evaluation papers or applications, and not even membership books. Not even dues. Where was I going to get money to pay dues?” Dorothy Ray Healey similarly recalled, “I never regularly paid dues until 1946. When you moved around a great deal, the way I did, the bookkeeping never kept up with you.” But, like Decker, she specified that “you could still be a Communist accepted by others as a Communist, whether you paid dues or not.” She added, “There is this myth that the Party ran like some kind of well-oiled machine, but it was never that well organized internally. . . . The FBI did a much better job of keeping track of our members than we did, unfortunately.”
lol
During the war the Bay Area became the largest shipbuilding site in the world. New shipyards and expansions of existing ones constructed some fourteen hundred ships, averaging more than one a day. This rapid expansion of shipbuilding produced a huge demand for workers. Some new workers were local, including many women. Others were recruited across the country, including significant numbers from the South, both white and Black. One consequence was the expansion or development of Black communities in San Francisco, Oakland, Richmond, and Marin County.
Most shipyards had contracts with the International Brotherhood of Boilermakers, AFL, which limited membership to whites. The 1937 Boilermakers’ national convention had created a special status for locals considered subject to “subversive forces,” that is, the CP: the national officers took direct control of such locals. Local 513, for Kaiser Shipyard workers at Richmond, was controlled that way throughout the war, with no elections or meetings. Workers at Marinship, in Marin County just north of the Golden Gate Bridge, were represented by Boilermakers Local 6, a long-established local in San Francisco. Faced with many Black workers in the Bay Area shipyards, the Boilermakers required them to pay dues to an auxiliary but denied them participation in elections or meetings.27 CP members on opposite sides of the bay took different approaches to fight this racial discrimination.
thinking about the parallels between that historical moment and our current one, with data centers for ai bullshit & silicon valley veering toward a steel-plated militarism whose targets are significantly less deserving. what is the point in merely bargaining for slightly better wages in a destructive industry? why not fight for a better world entirely? maybe because the former fight can actually be won whereas the latter seems hopelessly utopian and quixotic.
During the war the Bay Area became the largest shipbuilding site in the world. New shipyards and expansions of existing ones constructed some fourteen hundred ships, averaging more than one a day. This rapid expansion of shipbuilding produced a huge demand for workers. Some new workers were local, including many women. Others were recruited across the country, including significant numbers from the South, both white and Black. One consequence was the expansion or development of Black communities in San Francisco, Oakland, Richmond, and Marin County.
Most shipyards had contracts with the International Brotherhood of Boilermakers, AFL, which limited membership to whites. The 1937 Boilermakers’ national convention had created a special status for locals considered subject to “subversive forces,” that is, the CP: the national officers took direct control of such locals. Local 513, for Kaiser Shipyard workers at Richmond, was controlled that way throughout the war, with no elections or meetings. Workers at Marinship, in Marin County just north of the Golden Gate Bridge, were represented by Boilermakers Local 6, a long-established local in San Francisco. Faced with many Black workers in the Bay Area shipyards, the Boilermakers required them to pay dues to an auxiliary but denied them participation in elections or meetings.27 CP members on opposite sides of the bay took different approaches to fight this racial discrimination.
thinking about the parallels between that historical moment and our current one, with data centers for ai bullshit & silicon valley veering toward a steel-plated militarism whose targets are significantly less deserving. what is the point in merely bargaining for slightly better wages in a destructive industry? why not fight for a better world entirely? maybe because the former fight can actually be won whereas the latter seems hopelessly utopian and quixotic.
The Comintern had always been the most important channel for information from Moscow to New York, both through written material and, more importantly, through regular visits by top CPUSA leaders to Moscow for in-person discussions. Those channels were seriously interrupted from 1939 onward, as wars in Europe and Eastern Asia prevented U.S. party leaders from traveling to Moscow. The Comintern itself was dissolved in 1943. However, as Joseph Starobin has suggested, the leaders of the CPUSA carried in their heads a “mental Comintern,” an understanding that the party line in the United States should follow and accurately reflect the position of the Soviet party. Starobin was foreign editor of the Daily Worker from 1945 to 1954, in charge of the party’s peace activities, and a participant in many of the party’s high-level meetings; he resigned from the party in 1956 and later earned a PhD in political science from Columbia University. Here is his description of the way that party leaders after the 1940s sought to discern the intent of their Soviet leaders:
They lived in what can only be called “a mental Comintern,” imagining themselves part of something which did not exist. Seen in the best light, they were a species of self-proclaimed guerillas, operating in what they believed to be a world battle, but having no significant contact with any “main force” and without a perception of the battle plan. They resorted essentially to zodiac signs for guidance.8
omg lol
The Comintern had always been the most important channel for information from Moscow to New York, both through written material and, more importantly, through regular visits by top CPUSA leaders to Moscow for in-person discussions. Those channels were seriously interrupted from 1939 onward, as wars in Europe and Eastern Asia prevented U.S. party leaders from traveling to Moscow. The Comintern itself was dissolved in 1943. However, as Joseph Starobin has suggested, the leaders of the CPUSA carried in their heads a “mental Comintern,” an understanding that the party line in the United States should follow and accurately reflect the position of the Soviet party. Starobin was foreign editor of the Daily Worker from 1945 to 1954, in charge of the party’s peace activities, and a participant in many of the party’s high-level meetings; he resigned from the party in 1956 and later earned a PhD in political science from Columbia University. Here is his description of the way that party leaders after the 1940s sought to discern the intent of their Soviet leaders:
They lived in what can only be called “a mental Comintern,” imagining themselves part of something which did not exist. Seen in the best light, they were a species of self-proclaimed guerillas, operating in what they believed to be a world battle, but having no significant contact with any “main force” and without a perception of the battle plan. They resorted essentially to zodiac signs for guidance.8
omg lol
Other institutions joined the CLS in contributing to San Francisco’s postwar labor-left culture. People’s World continued to present reviews of art, music, literature, and film as well as sports and the party’s perspective on the news. Subscribers far outnumbered party members. In parts of San Francisco, PW had carriers making home deliveries, just like the mainstream dailies. Sidney Roger presented radio broadcasts of news from a left perspective on station KGO. He was a UCBerkeley graduate who had studied anthropology and drama and worked in the WPA Federal Theater Project. Roger never joined the CP but described himself as “very close to the Left.” He had a few CIO unions as sponsors but also set up the Sidney Roger Radio Fund, creating an early form of listener-sponsored radio. His broadcasts came to an end in 1950 when KGO canceled his contract.
nice
Other institutions joined the CLS in contributing to San Francisco’s postwar labor-left culture. People’s World continued to present reviews of art, music, literature, and film as well as sports and the party’s perspective on the news. Subscribers far outnumbered party members. In parts of San Francisco, PW had carriers making home deliveries, just like the mainstream dailies. Sidney Roger presented radio broadcasts of news from a left perspective on station KGO. He was a UCBerkeley graduate who had studied anthropology and drama and worked in the WPA Federal Theater Project. Roger never joined the CP but described himself as “very close to the Left.” He had a few CIO unions as sponsors but also set up the Sidney Roger Radio Fund, creating an early form of listener-sponsored radio. His broadcasts came to an end in 1950 when KGO canceled his contract.
nice